In our kitchen we've got two 58 watt 5 foot (1500 mm) fluorescent tubes, one of which is showing signs of age. I might replace them with LED equivalents, as with current electricity prices, the payback period would be only a year or two. But I'm not sure whether the replacements that I can see sold by the likes of Screwfix and Toolstation are adequate. The existing 58 watt tubes are rated at 5200 lumens, but the LED replacements drawing around 20 watts seem only to emit about 2000 lumens. So will they be bright enough - does anyone know? Maybe with LEDs all the lumens go downwards. Or can one get brighter equivalents from specialist retailers?
replacing fluorescent tube with LED
Dec 17, 2023
Last reply: 2 years ago
40 Replies
I replace mine with a strip of LED spotlights.
I put the 5' version of this in my kitchen 2 months ago:
formatting link
Kitchen is 15' x 10' and standard height, light is excellent, gets into every corner. When I decorate I will put spacers behind the brackets to allow more room for the flex.
You can get 24W tubes delivering 4000lm and as you say shining downwards probably not noticeably dimmer that (degraded old) 58W fluoros, e.g.
formatting link
Point to check is that your existing fittings are not high frequency types as fitting the LED tubes will require additional wiring alterations.
Cool white gives a much whiter light than warm white, so check the specs. Some people find it too bright but after a year or so the harshness softens (in my experience - that may be because I buy on price not quality).
There is a good selection at:
formatting link
(8 pages)
I need to upgrade my garage lighting this year, so I will be making a selection myself.
10 out of ten for spelling fluorescent correctly.
You may find it economical to take the whole fitting down and replace it with a LED batten light
Example (not recommendation)
formatting link
Seconded.
It might mean a bit of redecoration, but it's far better I think to replace the whole thing. And the modern LED fittings are a light as a feather.
Or that your cataracts are advancing. ;-). Seriously though, cataracts add a yellow tinge to your vision.
Tim
Cable entry point may be an issue for fitting replacement.
>
They also add a nice rainbow around every bright light you look at at night.
Any way of getting a clear indication of the power consumption of these jobs? The 6ft one is listed at 5W, the 5ft and shorter are variously 48W, 40W, 20W, and so on.
What is the *likly* consumption?
I bought one of those on DOTD (remember those?)
Very flimsy. If you want to run a series connected end to end you can't because they're double insulated, so you can't extend the CPC through one fitting to the next. Plastic clip-in ceiling brackets so the whole lot will come down in a fire. End cable entry untwists and exposes live terminals without the use of a tool.
For some reason my review pointing all this out wasn't accepted.
Owain
Ask them?
formatting link
Can't say I understand their figures. If you look at
formatting link
they say it is 2300lm, "equivalent to a 58W fluorescent". But a 58W fluo provides, as the OP pointed out, 5200lm (confirmed at
formatting link
). I thought the beam angle might have something to do with it, but they say their led tube is 320° (a fluo would be 360°). I hoped the explanation might be at
formatting link
, but I can't see the lumens chart with Pale Moon, Firefox, or Vivaldi.
The TLC fluo is £4.32 inc vat. If it works out that you need at least a couple of those BLT led tubes for an equivalent light output (more like
2.25x), you're not far off 58W. The Megaman is more efficient than the Crompton, though (22W for 2700lm).
The key is the directionality... I replaced a 36W 4' tube in our utility room with a Philips G13 T8 LED, which is claimed to produce
1600lm with 16W load. That is significantly less than the tube it replaced (or at least when new). However in reality I found that measuring the light level with a Lux meter in the room, they were in fact very nearly the same. The instant on, and no warm up time is nice as well.
I agree, the lumens chart does not show with Ubutu and Firefox. Nor even with Chrome, which will often display stuff that Firefox won't. Maybe somebody can try Windows and see if that works.
TLC's are 167lu/w and 330 deg.
formatting link
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required