OT: mathematical conundrum

Nov 22, 2015 94 Replies
Saved reading
Jump to replies (94)

Ok, let's try this:



If 'i' is the square root of minus 1, what is 'i' squared?


Bugger. You got it right straight away. I was hoping for a lengthy, argumentative thread on this!

that depends on whether you are a mathematicial or an engineer. The latter tend to use "i" for current.

I thought the whole point about "i" was that it ain't real.

Actually, it is. The label "imaginary numbers" is a misnomer.

Since when? I've always known it as 'i'. See also

formatting link

Whether it is or not, its square is still -1.

Is the wrong answer. No imaginary coconut for you, then!

I beg to differ: -1 x -1 = +1.

+1

(that's giving the answer AND agreeing with Tim. ;-)

i is j; they're the same thing. It's just that i already reserved in electronics and electrical engineering as the symbol for current, so in these disciplines we use j instead of i to avoid confusion.

Isn't that a bit like say: Pegasus without his wings is just an ordinary horse. It requires that Pegasus is there in the first place, surely?

One can IMHO reconcile the mathematical and engineering notations by defining j as equal to -i resulting in i * j = 1 - not to be confused with quaternions

For further amusement, see

formatting link
and the article containing it.

This thread was entitled "mathematical conundrum". I've yet to understand what the conundrum is, perhaps I missed it, if so could someone point it out?

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required