[OT] Car phone holder

Apr 02, 2021 Last reply: 5 years ago 26 Replies

My trusty holder broke to day and it is time for a new one.



Looking for one that can be fixed to the windscreen, just below the rear mirror, as I use the phone as my SatNav.



I always use my phone in landscape mode.



Important that it will hold firm - to the windscreen and will not bounce (too much, anyway) when the road is a little bumpy. The phone will not rest on the dashboard as the holder will be fixed too high for that (I like to be able to see the road below it). Sensible price too.



Does anyone have experience (good? bad?) with these two? Can recommend another suitable for the job?



formatting link
formatting link
Many thanks.


That doesn't sound like a safe location. Could it obscure something in front?

I can still see below it without a problem - there is a wide gap between it and the dashboard. Unlike when you rest the phone on the dashboard whihch clearly obscure your view of the road.

Been doing it from the day you could get a SatNav on a phone (pre-smart phone, maybe 15 years).

Never had an accident in my life.

make sure you remove it before MOT time......

Thanks. Never have done. Never failed.

Likewise. I have a dashcam and a mount for my phone that would normally be regarded as being in my vision for MOT purposes.

If it was an issue the guys at the MOT garage would simply remove them.

Is it legal to place a sat-nav there? It will fall into the same rules as hanging fluffy dice or an air freshener on the rear view mirror.

The thought that there was anything wrong with it, legally or otherwise, had never crossed my mind. Really. I did likewise with rental cars all over the world for many many years. Never a problem.

I would not have done so had I thought that it was impacting my view of the road. Reason I did it in the first place is because I thought that this was the least obstructive location to place a sat nav in a car.

I have had mine emoved by tester

Advisory notice item(s):

Items removed from driver's view prior to test () Nearside Rear Suspension arm corroded but not seriously weakened trailing arm (5.3.3 (b) (i)) Front Exhaust mounting defective hanger corroded and broken (6.1.2 (a)) Tyre slightly damaged/cracking or perishing both front cracked around shoulders 165x60x14 (5.2.3 (d) (ii)) Offside Front Play in steering rack inner joint(s) ()

indeed as they did mine

Until you have an accident and the obstruction of vision is sited as the cause. Also, from what I understand a sat-nav on a phone is classified as PHONE usage in the UK if you operate the sat-nav whilst on the move.

When has touching a phone in a hands free mode started to be an offence?

Can you do anything other than make a phone call in hands free mode?

Saying "Hello Google" for example will allow you to do many things on an Android phone. Follow that with "Navigate to..." or similar will start Google Maps, etc.

Good to see they're doing the job enthusiastically. They obviously care for your and others' safety.

Not if the phone is fixed to the car yet, though they plan to make hands free calls illegal.

I know the Transport Committee called for consideration of such a ban. But I can only recall plans to widen the ban on /hand-held/ use beyond calls, text, tweets etc to off-line stuff (eg playing music or taking videos). There was a consultation document on that last year.

OK so why over the years do advisories come and go like product on my headlights which was never there...it's a lottery...

hope they never ban hand held microphones.....

formatting link

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required