OT - Calc of Avg temperature

Feb 02, 2014 42 Replies
Saved reading
Jump to replies (42)

Somewhat embarassed to ask this. Helping daughter with h/work. How do you calc the avg when the temperature values range from below zero to above? And do you tell if the result is +ve or -ve after the division?



ag -3, -2, -5 , 0, 0, 3, 4, 5



Thanks.


No change to the rules add the values and divide by the number of values

total of 8 values = +2

average = 0.25 degrees

Sum them (answer +2)

Divide by the number of readings (8)

Answer +2/8 = 0.25

On Sunday 02 February 2014 18:55 charles wrote in uk.d-i-y:

Yes - that is the definition of average. and just to claify in the general case, if you end up with a -ve number, that's fine and should be stated (to covert to +ve would be an error).

Just checking :) And of course if the total is -ve then the avg will be

-ve.

Thanks.

Others have given the answer, which you can calculate in your head.

In the context of such a mixture of positive and negative data point an answer of +0.25C would be slightly better.

In article , Anthony R. Gold writes

Nah, I'd say it's reasonable to assume positive unless stated otherwise.

Never mind the average, that obviously positive proof of global warming, but as your daughter provided the data, definitely not man-made.

This is homework. The answer should follow the format of the question, which does not use plus signs.

Colin Bignell

Excel is more fun though :-)

If we?re being particular about whether to include the positive or negative sign to clarify, should we not have a discussion about:

average: mean, median or mode average: arithmetic or geometric (but it can?t be the latter as the latter doesn?t permit negative numbers)

On Monday 03 February 2014 10:22 Jethro_uk wrote in uk.d-i-y:

Arithmetic Mean - in common parlance, that is what "average" means...

The answer expected is probably the 0.25 as many have calculated.

However, in pedant mode, that's the average of these numbers. You can't use them to work out an average temperature - there's not enough data provided with just a few points at unknown times. At best, you could assume they are the average temperatures during equal sized sampling periods. If they are snapshot temperatures, then there's not enough data - it might have been -50 at some point between the second and third readings.

It is an arithmetic homework question. Homework questions work within the confines of the artificial world created for the purposes of the question, not in the real world. It is a long time since I needed to do school homework, but I still recall that trying to think outside the restraints of the course work was a very good way to lose marks. About the only exception was English, where a certain amount of creativity was encouraged.

Colin Bignell

Convert each to old money Fahrenheit using nearest available ready reckoner tables, add up values (all plusitive) then grab either log tables or a slide rule and divide by eight, using long division on a sheet of paper to verify accuracy. Convert back to celcius/centigrade figure or what not. Send kid to skool with an apple for teachie, laced with brandy.

It's a question about simple arithmetic. Trouble is these days even such trivial questions have to be wrapped up in a cuddly "real world" question so the little darlings don't suffer major psychological trauma, an infringement of their human rights.

Notwithstanding what Caprimulgus said, IME even having done such questions doesn't help children work out how to solve real-world problems; they still need to learn or be taught how to *apply* their knowledge.

I think you are both right. I had much the same thoughts as Mr Gabriel but also see we really need to know the context. Eg if the daughter is preparing for Oxford Admissions Tests I'd hope a little more than arithmetic *might* be involved ;)

Or do the same using Kelvin - no negative values to worry about - then go back to Celcius.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required