Dickering Flimmer Switch

Nov 06, 2012 14 Replies

Rate this thread:

The Medway Handyman 13 years ago

At SWMBOs request I fitted a dimmer switch in out dining room. It flickered on some settings, so I took it back to TLC who swapped it for another. It still piggin flickers!

It's a 400w Ultimate push dimmer with 15 'click' settings.

First 5 clicks show no discernible light, 6,7,8 fine, 9 flickers, 10,11 OK, 12 flickers faster, 13 flickers but not as fast, 14 & 15 OK.

Wired up as per instructions, live to L2, neutral to Comm. Tried L1 & Comm, no difference.

Lamp is a 40w LBC which, according to the packaging, is dimmable.

I've tried 3 lamps, but they all do the same.

Is 40w too low, or maybe the lamps aren't dimmable?

Any ideas before it drives me mad?

Vote

D.M.Chapman 13 years ago

I've certainly seen that before - sticking a 100w bulb in solved it. Harder to do know I guess :-)

You can get lower wattage ones - not sure how low they go though.

Darren

Vote

polygonum 13 years ago

Have a look here:

formatting link

there is a specific low-wattage version - or one of the V-pro range might work.

(Is that in time? Or have you already been driven?)

Vote

Ericp 13 years ago

The load is far too small for the switch. It barely knows it has one at 40w.

Vote

Andrew Gabriel 13 years ago

What's an LBC?

There are a few different dimmer designs.

Some have a minimum load, and for a 400W dimmer that's more likely to be 60W or 100W. Symptom if too low is that lamp goes out when dimmed dimmed past a certain point, and possibly flickers around the transition point.

Some will only dim filament lamps (or resistive loads).

Vote

Bob Eager 13 years ago

In other words, they go up to 11..but no more.

Vote

Graham. 13 years ago

The two wires to the switch are live and switch-wire, if it was live amd neutral you would have fireworks when you switched on.

The lamp might well be dimmable, but so is a 15w incandessent pigmy bulb, but a single one will flicker with most dimmers.

What is an LBC?

Vote

The Medway Handyman 13 years ago

Large bayonet cap.

Vote

DerbyBorn 13 years ago

The Medway Handyman wrote in news:VUfms.222896 $ snipped-for-privacy@fx08.am:

Most 400 watt dimmers require a 60watt minimum load.

Vote

charles 13 years ago

The 1" diam one? I haven't seen one for years

most domestic ones are simply BC (bayonet cap)

Vote

Ian 13 years ago

Hello Graham,

LBC - Lampe Basse Consommation (French: Energy Saving Lamps)

ttfn Ian.

Vote

Ian 13 years ago

Hello Graham,

LBC - Lampe Basse Consommation (French: Energy Saving Lamps)

ttfn Ian.

Vote

robgraham 13 years ago

+1 - I've just removed one from a friend's house; it has always flickered since she moved in because the previous owner had fitted it for a lampshade that only allowed 40W bulbs. Worked fine when I out a larger bulb on to it.

Doesn't say much for TLC that they didn't flag that up to you TMH - the one I took out says 60 to 400W on it.

Rob

Vote

charles 13 years ago

[Snip]

TLC are a wholesaler, not an advice bureaux. You are supposed to know what you are buying.

Mind you some of their staff are incredibly helpful.

Vote

The Medway Handyman 13 years ago

Thanks to all who replied, 60w 'normal' lamp and all is well.

What a great NG!

Vote

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required