Sheet-metal nibbler: pneumatic vs. hand-powered

Jul 08, 2009 7 Replies

Rate this thread:

Matt 17 years ago

I want to cut some sheet steel. I expect I might have to make several feet of cuts at a time, and I might need to make ten feet of cuts in a few months. I expect the material will be 304 stainless or similar, say around 22 ga. (0.031 inches) give or take 20%.

Would it likely be unpleasant to use a muscle-powered nibbler? Should I just plan on a pneumatic nibbler? Would I likely see much difference in the finished product? I'm not set up for air tools right now, but I could probably rent something ...

Please advise.

Vote

salty 17 years ago

This "might" be okay for occasional use on 22 gauge stainless. Probably worth $50 to find out.

formatting link

I don't think you are going to like trying to do what you propose with a hand powered nibbler.

Vote

charlie 17 years ago

it might be just easier and cheaper to find someone with a shear that would make a couple of cuts. perhaps where you're getting the metal in the first place.

Vote

gfretwell 17 years ago

If they are straight cuts you can do a fairly good job with a metal cutoff wheel in a circular saw. Be sure the nibbler you use is rated for stainless. I broke mine on some 22 ga (316 or so). It was "kitchen grade" whatever that is. There are actually a lot more grades than 316 and 304 but they seem to be the main benchmarks, based on whether it is mildly magnetic or not..

Vote

Stormin Mormon 17 years ago

I got a nibbler from Harbor Freight, which has served me well. Electric plug in. No compressor needed.

Vote

RicodJour 17 years ago

Ten feet of cuts in a few months is only a few inches per day. You should be able to do that with either tool.

Vote

Matt 16 years ago

Thanks guys for all the replies ... will consider ...

Vote

JIMMIE 16 years ago

If you already had a compressor I would say get the Pneumatic one otherwise I would get an elctric.

Jimmie

Vote

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required