My landlord is having a problem with this thing. You're supposed to
replace all your outlets and wall switches with control modules, then
you can operate any electrical equipment in your house remotely or on
a schedule. The manual is sketchy, but it looks like the control
center sends a 2.4 ghz signal through the house wires that operate
the control modules. It works somewhat, but it screws some things up.
Like it will manually dim a light, until it goes all the way off, but
then it won't come back on again.
We have an ISP across the street that broadcasts a wireless internet
signal at 2.4 ghz. Could that be causing problems?
The model number of this device is 61-2470. Thanks.
The signal it sends isn't 2.4 GHz (or even close!) The WISP would not be
causing the problem. I have a similar system in my home and it was
problematic when my electric truck was charging. A power line filter on the
truck power control unit solved the problem.
Find the source of the problem (something plugged into the power line) by
unplugging things one at a time. Then install the appropriate filter on the
offending device. Here are some filters:
On Wed, 02 Jul 2003 11:50:14 -0500, "R. Gregg Reed"
thats an X10 device. X10 is notorious for requiring very clean power
lines for it to work properly. That just about means plug-in filters
for anything electronic in your house. Well, maybe not that bad, but I
have filters on all my computers and monitors, TV, audio amp,
subwoofer, even the stove with its microprocessor. Operation was
really erratic until I did all this...
I guess even before you do the filtering is to check that the
transmitter is on the same powerline phase as the receiver. the X10
signal wont hop phases. You may get it to work sometimes but operation
will be very erratic. If they're on different phases, you may need to
buy a phase coupler. www.smarthome.com is a good place for all this
Radio Shack kind of lures people into buying this stuff but never
mentions that it takes a lot more time and effort to clean your power
line to make it operate reliably. For simple systems it may work
fine, but usually it doesnt unless you spend a lot more.
BTW, x10 works on a 120kHz carrier, not 2.4GHz, if your interested
here's a link explaining it:
This website is also a good site to buy modules and other X10 devices
but watch out for their email spam.
I have spent a lot of time in commercial buildings and residences
troubleshooting this technology. Some people refer to it as X10 because BSR
was one of the first companies 20 or so years ago that developed it and
marketed it under the X10 name.
Now there are several manufacturers of these products including Leviton
(Decora Home Controls) and Advanced Control Technologies (A10). Radio Shack
also has their own version. Much of the technology is interchangeable.
After all that I have experienced, I am reluctant to recommend the use of
this equipment except as a last resort. I have seen modules work on one
day and the next day don't work, but the day after that work again. My
conclusion is that the equipment never works 100% of the time. 99% under
the best circumstances is what you should expect. I have had other
electrical contractors consult with me after they have installed this
technology in a building or residence because they were getting tired of all
Electrical interference can be a big problem. Motors, computers, and
everything else connected to your power system can inhibit that signal
traveling across your existing circuits. Another problem that arises from
time to time is neighbors controlling each others lights from their home.
One contractor I know was really pushing the use of this technology and made
several sales and installations in the same neighborhoods. He particularly
would use the modules for outdoor lighting. Neighbors would talk to each
other and then call up this contractor to install the same set-up in their
home. I had cautioned this guy about the use of this technology based on my
experiences, but he figured that since the customers were asking for it, he
would give it to them. After several installations on the same street he
kept receiving callbacks. The customers were complaining that their lights
were going on and off at all different times of day and night. The
contractor did not pay much attention to the choice of address codes for
each residence when he did each installation. The neighbors all had the
same codes and were able to turn each others lights on and off. This is
especially true when each neighbor's power is from the same utility company
transformer. This contractor had to go back to each customer's house and
change the codes so that each house was different. It cost him a lot of
time and manpower to do this. Now he tells me that he cautions his
customers about the downside of this type of installation and only
recommends it when it is more cost effective.
The manufacturers produce amplifiers, couplers, controllers, signal strength
meters and other components to get a good signal and measure it at each
module location. Troubleshooting is a very time consuming process. You are
not working with wires that have become loose or broken although a loose
connection can affect performance also. You are fixing something that you
cannot see or feel. If you don't have the equipment to test the signal it
is difficult to see what the actual problem may be.
I couldn't say with certainty that the internet service provider across from
your location was causing a problem, but I would consider it a possibility.
Try contacting the manufacturer of your components for technical support.
I expect that this technology will be around for a long time as it is an
easy way to modernize an old house into a "Smart House". I also expect that
the manufacturers will continue to improve the functionality and reliability
of their systems. My recommendation for anyone considering this type of
installation is to plan carefully. Don't go around and replace every switch
and receptacle, but only the ones that you really want to be controlled from
a central or remote location or by computer. Also take into consideration
that it is not just a matter of replacing a switch or receptacle. You
should also install a coupling device across your phases in the electrical
panel. A big house or building should have an amplifier and a repeater.
Ideally the circuits used for these components should not have any other
equipment connected to them, but that would be difficult to achieve in a
I hope this information helps.
Based on my experence with X-10, you are providing very good advise. I use
X-10 for non-critical applications such as turning on china cabinet lights
for six hours at sundown, or nightlights, etc.
I have found that surge suppressors are the biggest problem in blocking X-10
Do you have a signal bridge between the two hot sides of the line?
Putting an X10 device on one 117v phase, with the transmitter on
the other, will definitely make operation unreliable unless you bridge
"R. Gregg Reed" wrote:
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.