Overcharging the battery

Jun 09, 2021 Last reply: 5 years ago 15 Replies

How come my Sandisk Clip Sport says one cannot ovrcharge the battery, but none of my smartphones have ever said that?


Am 09.06.21 um 23:25 schrieb micky:

So what! Did your house burn down? Hint: Charging electronics.

Conversely my smartphone (Moto G3) instructions specifically did say that. Wrongly, though: the battery bulged and burst the screen out of the casing.

It's not a smart phone and deals only with one Li-Ion cell battery. Protection electronics and charge limiters for that purpose are commodities. I've never had a small MP3 player with battery issues.

They're claiming something that all previous competition took for granted, to increase meaningless advertizing content.

Your smart phone has a more advanced and more complicated battery. New developments or manufacturing changes will have issues without a strict discipline that is often not present in that competitive arena.

RL

Guess that I have been lucky. I only use my cell phone when away from the house. At hone it stays on the charger all the time, maybe several days. I have done this to a flip phone and 2 smart phones and so far no problems.

Am 10.06.21 um 20:33 schrieb Ralph Mowery:

With Li-Ion batteries there are no problems anyway and the rest is done by the electronics. Care free I would say.

Might not have been the charging that was at fault. I had a phone's battery swell and pop open the case while off the charger and at less than full charge. I just replaced the battery and the phone never had another problem until I traded it for a new one well over a year later. Bad batteries happen...

What "no problems"? Like the well-publicised fires, recalls etc? Airlines seem to care rather a lot...

There are no bad batteries. Only batteries that do bad things.

Like children!

They don't. The real problem are the batteries of the s***ty B-787.

That sounds like an ultra cheap non-device-manufacturer-standard replacement battery.

Have you not read the strictures applied to how you transport your gadgets' batteries? Admittedly the caring is about their aeroplanes; they like the batteries to be close to the passenger, to act as a fire detector...

I've got a Novatel MiFi and their batteries are prone to pregnancy. They tell you to not leave it plugged in but I use it for internet access 24/7.

One of our clients send in a laptop for testing with our products and included the same model. It arrived without the back cover because of the bulging.

People using such crap are irresponsible.

*EOD* for me.

It was the original battery that came in a new iPhone. The phone was around a year old when the failure occurred. I replaced it with your well described ultra cheap (US$30 including tools) non-device-manufacturer-standard replacement battery. Fortunately that battery worked fine for the following year+ until the phone was finally replaced.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required