Our house is 15 years old. We last had it stained 8 years ago, with 2 coats semi-transparent Cabot stain.
We have 2 main "paint" stores in town that specialize in just paint, etc. One carries Cabot stain and Benjamin Moore paint. The other has their own stain and paint that they custom-mix for you, based on the Woodmaster brand. I'm getting conflicting information from them.
The Cabot store recommended their Pro.V.T. solid stain. This is 100% Acrylic. Does not come in an Oil version. They also have O.V.T. solid stains, which are available in either Acrylic or Oil-based.
The custom store recommended Oil-Based solid stain, since it's been 8 years since the house has been done, and the wood is probably quite dry. He said the oil-based will put moisture back into the wood, preventing further cracking, cupping, etc. He did also say that if we wanted to, we could put down the oil-based stain first, then go over it with Acrylic, which would help with sealing the wood against moisture, mildew, etc. than just using straight Oil-based would.
I understand that Cabot is quite expensive. The custom store said that a lot of local contractors/painters get their paint from them (which I know is true), and it's probably about 25% less expensive than the Cabot's. He compared their stain quality with the Cabot O.V.T.
What to do????