HF single speed -or- variable speed multi-tool?

Sep 03, 2011 3 Replies

Any thoughts on which to buy?



I got the single speed - 20K oscillations -- last week for $20 and added $20 in accessories.



This week, the variable speed version is $40 with about those same $20 in accessories, so the price is a wash.



The single speed one is pretty decent IMO. Old reviews talk about it's "boxy" feel, but it's been redesigned and now is 20,000 oscillations vs 10K, so does a decent job. For $20, hard to beat. But now with the variable speed one coming in at basically the same price with the extra accessories, should I swap them out?



Unless it has changed the multi is really only two speed, not a true multi, IMO.

I have no plans to upgrade.

That is generally my opinion of multi-speed as well -- other than a drill press, when is anything other than "fast" used? But when I was cutting a small piece of weather stripping, I thought maybe slowing it down a tad would give me a bit more accuracy.

I went to HF this eve -- came home with the same one I already had.

While there -- I was looking over the "blue" var-speed version. Everything about it just seemed less polished. The off/on switch, the enclosure, etc. As noted earlier, with the accessories (scraper, 2 wood blades, and sanding pad) it would seem a good deal. But my 5 year old noticed a plug-in nearby and "daddy" wasted no time. When I plugged in the var-speed one, it seemed to hesitate.. then come up to speed after a few secs. Well, maybe that is a "soft-start" feature, or just a bad luck of the draw, but it seemed to indicate lesser quality than the "red", uni-speed, version I had just used yesterday. The uni-speed one seems perhaps to be the latest design, it "feels" a little better and at least in my case, ran better. For $20, I guess I'll stay with it for now.. unless I can come across a Dremel for $55 or so (overstock is out of stock at $79). It not already, check-out fitzallblades.com I've not ordered any yet, but their prices are 35% below even HF prices.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required