I recently purchased some motion sensors to control the lights in our
hallway. There are three locations where they will be installed.
These sensors, Pass & Seymour RW3U600, require a neutral and one
location has no neutral.
Can I bring a neutral from a nearby receptacle that is on a different
circuit or must the neutral be the same that is used by this lighting
circuit?
On 03/21/2013 11:21 AM, snipped-for-privacy@aol.com wrote:
I'm guessing this is a switch leg? do you have access from the attic?
additional complication - you state "hallway" singular but "locations"
plural. This implies to me that you have at least three switches
controlling one light or group of lights. That means that these motion
sensors should be 3-way or 4-way type with the one in the middle of the
run being a 4-way. The spec sheet for this devices lists it as 3-way
not 4-way.
https://images.tradeservice.com/9ETBOIYK8205G6UU/ATTACHMENTS/DIR100014/PASSEME00672_3.pdf
Additionally if the device requires a neutral you would need to run the
neutral to all three locations, not just the closest one, which means
you may have to source some 4w+G Romex and may be running into box fill
problems... not saying you can't do this, but you might be looking at a
bigger project (e.g. breaking the boxes out of the wall, replacing with
deep boxes, repulling wire) than you originally thought.
Have you sketched out the wiring for the light and the three switches as
it exists now? If you could post that on photobucket or something we
might be more help.
nate
--
replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply.
http://members.cox.net/njnagel
If I understand the definition of "switch leg" correctly the answer to
your question is no... I think. These switches control the ceiling
lights in two intersecting hallways. The "intersecting hallways"
answers another question of yours.
The spec sheet does say only 3-way but their web page says 3-way and
4-way and their tech support claims as many as six (6) sensors can be
wired together to control one light or group of lights.
http://www.legrand.us/passandseymour/motion-sensors/3-way-occupancy-vacancy/rw3u600la.aspx#.USUteGcWSSo
Currently the only location that has no neutral is the location where
the 4-way switch is located. The location where the load is
connected to has a neutral but it is from a different circuit as well.
That's why I only asked about the one location.
I do have access to the attic. It does appear that I have a lot more
work ahead of me than I planned. Crap.
I have up loaded two images to photobucket.
http://s692.photobucket.com/user/dobripw/library/Wiring%20Schematic?page=1
One shows the wiring as it is today and the other shows how the three
sensors will be wired. If you see anything that's wrong let me know.
Thanks
*I looked at the diagram of the existing circuit and it doesn't seem right
to me. Normally one box would have a two wire feed and a three wire that
goes to the next box with two travelers and carries the neutral along with
it. At the other end should be a two wire that goes to the light fixtures
and the three wire with travelers and neutral. You are showing the neutral
going to the lights all by itself. The four-way switch should have two sets
of travelers and the neutral passing through.
Regardless, I had a thought. Since these are motion sensors they don't need
to be three-way. Perhaps you could just wire single pole units at each
location. You would just need to change some of the splices in the existing
wiring to make sure that you have a neutral, hot, switch leg, and ground at
each location. Basically putting all of the sensors in parallel. You would
lose the ability to turn on at one location and off at another manually.
On Thu, 21 Mar 2013 17:58:53 -0400, "John Grabowski"
John you can also wire a 3/4 way switch loop with the hot going down
and the travelers coming back. (or the other way, travelers going
down, switched leg coming back)
*Yes, but based on the wiring diagram the OP presented, I'm not sure what he
already has in place. He is only showing a two wire in and a two wire out
at the 4-way. Maybe that is why a neutral at the load side was borrowed
from another circuit.
On 03/21/2013 07:24 PM, snipped-for-privacy@aol.com wrote:
I'm thinking that this is actually a hybrid of that and the standard
configuration, since the OP said that there were neutrals in two of the
boxes but not another - panel box -> switch 1 -> switch 2 -> light
fixture -> switch 3
so if that is the case he will have to repull the cable between the
light fixture and switch 3 but that is just supposition at this point
nate
--
replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply.
http://members.cox.net/njnagel
Something's not right here. If your sketch is correct then by the NEC
the neutral must be present in the "family room" switch box because the
sums of the currents in a given cable/raceway must sum to zero.
You sure it's not a switch leg, or that your diagram is accurate?
(I'm not saying that you're wrong, just that *something* is wrong...)
nate
--
replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply.
http://members.cox.net/njnagel
I am definitely NOT sure it's not a switch leg. I am positive both
diagrams are correct. The sensors work as they should when I
temporarily borrowed an existing neutral at the two locations that
didn't have it for that circuit.
We bought the house when it was new forty years ago. Did the NEC
require a neutral at the family room location then?
There are situations where a neutral may not be required to be present,
but if your diagram is accurate then it is. The requirement (prior to
the current NEC) is not that the neutral to be present, but that all the
conductors in a cable sum to zero (to minimize potential inductive
heating.) So the neutral needs to be present in the cable running from
the "hallway" switch to the "family room" switch and likewise from the
"family room" to the "foyer." Otherwise let's just say for the sake of
argument that it's a 120W light bulb to make round numbers, you'd have
1A flowing through the "hot" traveler in each cable and no current in
the disconnected traveler - that doesn't sum to zero. Likewise you have
a neutral with a -1A current somewhere else. (I know it's AC, I'm just
using the convention of "hot" = positive and "neutral" = negative for
purposes of simplicity, since the currents will in actual fact oppose
each other at all times) That's not legal...
However, disassemble the family room switch box again. If your diagram
is truly correct, the neutral should be there, and spliced through
(likely with a wire nut, if the house is only 40 years old) hidden in
the back of the box.
nate
--
replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply.
http://members.cox.net/njnagel
I have done some more investigation and have discovered I could be
wrong. I can't believe I said that. Thank you Nate, for encouraging
me to look deeper.
My original conclusion was the wires going to the load originated at
the box in the foyer I believe is wrong. The wires going to the load
originate in the hallway.
I have uploaded a revised image to:
http://s692.photobucket.com/user/dobripw/media/Wiring%20Schematic/Schematic-PampSRW3U600Revised.png.html?sort=3&o=0
What is the red wire going to all of the boxes and presumably the
load?
That diagram has the correct wires, except for the three wires going to
the load. There should only be two unless they're carrying a feed to go
somewhere else. The red wire, the way you drew the diagram, would be the
common, and would just be spliced through at the 4 way.
*Much better. The red wire appears to be the load as it is spliced through
to the last 3-way and should be attached to the darker screw on the 3-way
switch. As RBM pointed out, the three wire going to the lights has a line,
load, and neutral wire. It is also possible that the hot and neutral comes
from the light to feed the switches and the red is the load returning to the
light.
Based on the diagram that you provided from Pass and Seymour, you may be
able to install the 3-way motion sensors after changing the splices so that
you have a hot (Black), neutral (White), and traveler (Red connected to
yellow) at each box. The load (Red connected to red) gets spliced at the
one box. This appears to be a digital control and not entirely mechanical
which would require a fourth load wire at each location.
And if that one won't work under those conditions, Lutron
Maestro series has a multi location dimmer that include a motion
sensor,
will work CFL, etc, requires only hot, neutral and one wire
between switches and you can hook together up to 10 of
them that way. That series of dimmers is really nice.
Looking at that now, if the white is one of the travelers in all boxes,
it would appear that the whole thing is a long 3-way switch leg with no
neutral. I think at this point the next step is to drop the light
fixture and see what's in there. The only thing that doesn't add up now
is the red in the cable going to the load, that only needs to be a
2-wire cable (by the old code.)
What I suspect that you'll find is the line coming into the ceiling box,
a 2-wire cable going to the first switch location, then a 3-wire cable
(I'm not counting grounds in any of this) going to the other two switch
locations.
The red wire in the 3-wire cable, and then one of the wires in the
2-wire cable (I've seen it done both ways) will be the switched hot
returning from the last 3-way to the load in the ceiling box. the other
wire in the 2-wire cable is unswitched hot.
nate
--
replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply.
http://members.cox.net/njnagel
http://i1058.photobucket.com/albums/t402/thatguyN8/switchleg_zps48938a86.jpg
Unfortunately, if I'm right, you've got three runs of cable to repull.
(my apologies for quick and dirty sketch, but for things like this I'm
far more comfortable with a drafting pencil and cocktail napkin than a
computer program...)
nate
--
replace "roosters" with "cox" to reply.
http://members.cox.net/njnagel
*I see no reason to pull any new wires. Based on the information that
Gordon has provided, he has the necessary conductors. He just needs to
change a few splices. He needs to connect all of the whites together in the
box with the line and load which will give him a neutral at each location.
The blacks get connected together to provide a hot at each location. The
existing red wire that goes from switch to switch gets connected to the
yellow on the motion sensor. The red on the motion sensor in the box with
the line and load gets connected to the red going to the lights.
I don't think the details, including switch connections are shown
correctly at the right end box. Is there only one (3-wire) run? The
wires (but not connection) make sense if there is another 2-wire
connection and power feeds through the box. Otherwise, as Nate says,
there only need to be 2 wires to the light.
*IF* the number of wires shown is correct the P&S devices can be used.
As John notes, these are not normal 3-way switches. Contrary to the
labeling on the P&S diagram, The sensors interconnect with a hot,
neutral and control wire. The singe control wire switches the devices
between on and off. There need to be 3 wires between devices (which
there are). At the right end feed point there need to be 3 wires (hot,
neutral and switch leg) to the light, which is what the diagram shows.
If he definitely has three wires going from the end switch to the
lights, it's either got to be bringing a feed and switch leg up from the
switch or down from the lights, either way the devices will work as John
describes
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.