Electric space heater question

We have one of those electric heat-dish-parabolic space heaters that I was using in my living room since my fireplace is on the fritz.

formatting link
Do those things put off carbon monoxide?

Olddog

Reply to
olddog
Loading thread data ...

formatting link

Electric heater give off carbon monoxide? LOL ;)

Reply to
Frank

formatting link

I would of thought it was funny too but my detector went off and it was right by my space heater. Hell...I don't know. It's invisible and odorless.

olddog

Reply to
olddog

What set it off was dust burning off, mine always stink for 15 minutes after a year sitting, put a plastic bag over it when you store it for the summer. So actualy for a minute it could have put out minimal Co, but it was just dust burning off.

Reply to
ransley

No. To get CO, you have to have combustion.

Reply to
Robert Neville

Blow cigarette smoke into a co detector, it registers, burn dust off a

800f element it will register Co.
Reply to
ransley

And cigarette smoke comes from the combustion of tobacco, not an electric heater element.

And if you have anything more than a momentary blip of CO from dust on the elements, you have bigger problems.

The bottom line is that a normally operting electric heater does not produce CO.

Reply to
Robert Neville

only if you tip it back and burn your trash on it.

s

formatting link

Reply to
Steve Barker

I stronly suspect it was your SMOKE detector - not a CO detector that went off.

Reply to
clare

It was strange. I've had that detector on for two years and never a peep. This morning I got up and grabbed the remote and aimed it at the TV near the detector and it went off. My natural gas fireplace WAS causing problems with soot so turned it off days ago but the detector never went off.

I put my space heater on my fireplace and the detector went off for just a couple of seconds when I aimed the remote at it.

Weird

olddog

Reply to
olddog

No I've got a smoke detector too. I checked it and it's fine. I got the CO detector when I bought this house to be on the safe side. ;-)

olddog

Reply to
olddog

NO! Actually you have to have INCOMPLETE combustion. Bubba

Reply to
Bubba

Ahh, but incomplete combustion is combustion... :)

Reply to
Robert Neville

I'm thinking that ransley has it right. Even though I dusted it it still burned off. Good call.

I cleared the detector and it hasn't gone off again.

olddog

Reply to
olddog

One of the benefits of electric heat is that there are no toxic gases produced. For the most part, you need combustion (burning) to get CO.

Reply to
Phisherman

No gasses at your house, but the power plant may produce a lot of them. Electric is 100% efficient for the user, but rather poorly efficient use of fuel to make it. That is why electric cars are a joke.

Reply to
Ed Pawlowski

formatting link

If the heater hurls enough insults at carbon monoxide, I would imagine that it would be put off.

TDD

Reply to
The Daring Dufas

So you are not buying a 40,000 Chevy Volt that might only go 10 miles at 0f. I dont think the Volt will do to well the way things are now.

Reply to
ransley

a tenant of mine had their detector go off christmas day years ago. me police fire department and finally a furnace service guy at holiday rates :( all on the scene.......

finally traced to the kitchens cooking activities, after all it was christmas dinner.......

wierdly I had a nice time that day, a fond memory

Reply to
hallerb

formatting link

No. And if it's like the $25 one I got at Costco, I love it. You can feel the heat ten feet away.

Steve

Reply to
SteveB

HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.