OTOH, my next door neighbor had a high-efficiency model installed in
her home way back when they were fairly new on the market (80s? early
90s?). So far, only one service call. In fact, she's dead, but the
furnace has kept on through two additional owners.
On Tue, 03 Dec 2013 08:45:21 -0500, Stormin Mormon
I've seen too many high eff furnaces fail eithin 5 years. My
brother's had a circuit board replaced at $400+ a shot 3 times? bedore
the furnace contractor offered him a real deal on a different
manufacturer's replacement - and after it was replaced he found there
was an $80 generic replacement board that would have fixed it - and
didn't suffer from premature death syndrome
You've met him, have you?? A genius at his feild of expertise -
setting up condominium plans. Not terribly bright about a lot of other
And I bet in comparison to either of us you are dumber than a sack of
On Tuesday, December 3, 2013 1:19:40 PM UTC-8, VinnyB wrote:
Because he has hired a cleaner, cook, nanny, etc. to do what the wife would be doing if not stationed at the window watching for service trucks. I hope he lets her at least listen to radio or do puzzles during the long truck-free intervals.
Why, we're neighborly, y'know? We talk, we even visit each other.
Hell, we even take turns mowing each other's lawns and blowing out
each other's driveways.
Every autumn I'm the most popular person in the neighborhood. I make
the rounds on my tractor and people wave me over to their yard to make
their leaves disappear. Folks love not having to rake.
I had an inexpensive no-frills (I have a small house) high-efficiency
furnace installed nine years ago. So far, no problems.
Our urnace has 10 yr P&L warranty. After that I fix it myself if
something goes wrong. Easy to get parts for Carrier furnace. I chose
X13 blower motor with speed selection taps, not the VS type which
has frequent controller problems.
You can usually get a Service Contract-mine is through the Gas Co--and it
covers all the components that you mentioned. My only problem with a 6 yr
92% was the flame sensor. Other than the contract cost my out pocket $$$$
was Zero. Actually, you saved money if these were the first costs you've had
in 9 yrs vs paying for a contract over that time frame.
Gas company periodically sends a flyer on how you're doing relative to the
average users and to neighbors. My fuel costs are only 4% higher than the
most efficient and way better (lower) than all the others. So fuel cost
savings is a major factor.
On Tuesday, December 3, 2013 1:27:39 AM UTC-5, Big Giant Head wrote:
I'd look at pricing of Rheem/Ruud vs the brands that are perceived as
being better. I had a Ruud that I replaced a few years ago that was
25 years old and still running. I don't know the whole history, but
it was 10 years old when I bought the house and except for putting a
hard-start kit on the AC, I didn't have any repair bills for my 15 years.
I replaced it with a Rheem, they are made by the same company. When
I looked at reviews a few years ago, according to Consumer Reports,
the repair/problem history of all the brands was about the same. In
fact, I recall Rheem was actually a little better than some of the
brands that spend a lot of $$$ on advertising. I'd rather have a Ruud
installed by the best installer, instead of a higher price system
installed by a crappy installer.
I'm curious what tax credits still exist? Back in 2010, you could
get a 30% fed tax credit up to $1500, but I thought that was all gone
How much you save each year in operating costs is unknown, because
only you know where you live and how much gas you use. GA and MN
are going to be very different. In a cold climate 80% vs 93%
for 20 years is going to add up and the cost of the eqpt difference
isn't that great. Install of a new one however is typically going
to cost more. Also, what else is on the chimney for the existing furnace?
If there is a water heater sharing the same chimney, you'll likely
need to install a chimney liner for that. It's not a big deal, but
does add to the cost. The other option is to go with a new direct
vent water heater, if the WH is near it's EOL too.
There is truth that high efficiency units are more complex, so there
are more things that can go wrong. On the other hand, I now have
a cumulative 13 years of experience with 3 of them and haven't had
a problem yet. And if you have reasonable diagnostic skills, no reason
you can't fix them yourself. They do have wiring diagrams and if you
understand the theory of how they work, etc, they are certainly a lot
easier to diagnose and fix than many systems on a modern car.
I would also recommend putting in a whole house surge protector if
you don't already have one. Unlike an old furnace, these have
electronics, including in many cases an ECM motor.
The WH shares the same pipe. The proposal for the super high efficiency
furnace calls for a new PVC tube through the roof, some sort of coaxial
thing that also brings down combustion air. It's a ranch with the roof
only maybe 6 feet or so above the ceiling level at that point.
BTW, the old unit is 90,000 BTH/H input. The proposals match that for
regular furnaces including two stage burner/fan but 80,000 BTU/H for the
On Tuesday, December 3, 2013 3:36:09 PM UTC-5, Big Giant Head wrote:
As others have pointed out it's really pretty simple. Try to make an estim
ate of your annual heating costs. Since you have a gas hw heater and proba
bly some other gas appliances to do that you will need to calculate your av
erage monthly summer gas cost and subtract that from your average monthly w
inter gas costs. Then multiple the results by the typical number of months
you heat and again by 16%. That will be your estimated annual savings. D
ivide that into the cost difference between replacing with another 80% unit
verses the 96% unit. That will give you the recovery years to break even.
The complexity is another issue that's completely unpredictable. Millions
of people have many years of uninterrupted service from a high efficiency u
nit. But occasionally they have problems. And they do tend to be more exp
ensive to fix.
BTW, should I even ask about replacing the HX or is that completely
ridiculous on a 26 year old unit? Actually, over the years I replaced a
gas valve, inducer motor, and inducer control board (new one has the time
delay) myself. So aside from the blower and a small circuit board, it's
just a box to hold these components, right?
I'm hoping someone is offering one with spark ignition. The more I learn
about hot surface ignitors the less I want one since I know it's going to
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.