Went up into the attic today to run a line for a new ceiling fan in the den, and about two feet from the access hatch I found a single plastic box nailed to a stud that looks like it's holding half the house togehter. Six or seven cables going into it, a fistful of splices held with red wire nuts, and half the splices are poking out the front with no cover on the box at all. Somebody did at least write notes on the wire jacket in sharpie, wich was oddly helpful. I flipped the breaker before touching anything and nothing in there looks burnt or melted, just seriously crowded. So what's the actual right fix here? Can I pull everything out, swap that box for a deeper one, and redo the splices neatly? Or is there a point where you split the mess into two boxes and give each one a real job? Also, does a box like this need a cover even up in an attic where nobody ever sees it? I'd rather fix it once and fix it right than shove the nuts back in and walk away. Anyone else found one of these blobs hiding above thier ceiling?
How do I clean up an overstuffed junction box in my attic?
Nov 09, 2026
Last reply: 1 week ago
5 Replies
Follow replies to this discussion?
First reply
That box sounds like it started life as a legit junction point and then every future project in the house just dumped another cable into it instead of making their own box. I pulled one almost identical out of my mom's garage ceiling a couple years back, same deal, red nuts…
Read the full replyInformation here may be outdated?
That box sounds like it started life as a legit junction point and then every future project in the house just dumped another cable into it instead of making their own box. I pulled one almost identical out of my mom's garage ceiling a couple years back, same deal, red nuts everywhere and no cover.
The fix you're describing is exactly right. Kill the breaker like you already did, pull everything out, and count what's actually in there. Box fill is the real question, and you can figure it with the chart printed on the inside of most box covers or easily found online. Every 14 gauge conductor counts as one unit, grounds together count as one total, and the wire nuts don't count at all. Once you add it up you'll probably find a single gang box was never legal for that many cables in the first place, which is why it looks like a canned ham.
Two options that both work. If the count fits, get a deep old work box or a two gang plastic box and redo the splices in there. While you're at it, trim the outer jacket back so only the individual conductors run into the box. A few inches of jacket inside eats fill space for nothing. If the count is too big for anything reasonable, split it. Find a natural place to cut the mess in half, run a short jumper of the right gauge between two boxes, and give each box a job, like one handles the lighting circuits and the other handles whatever else is passing through. Two clean boxes beat one packed one every time. And yes, it needs a cover, even in an attic. Attics are exactly where you get blown insulation, stray joist-hung Christmas lights, and critters, and an open splice box is how attic fires start. A blank cover on a two gang box costs a couple bucks. Take a phone photo of your finished splices and sharpie a label on the cover, future you will be grateful.
Tag every cable with masking tape and a number before you unwind a single nut, and note which box position each one came from. I learned that the hard way redoing a mess in my brother-in-law's workshop years back, got cocky, unspliced eight conductors at once, and spent the evening reverse-engineering somebody else's brain. The notes on the jacket tell me whoever did that was smarter than most. Way back when, the old-timers I apprenticed under soldered and taped every splice in a steel four-square box and never lost sleep over fill, but a deep plastic box with a blank cover is the modern way and it's a lot less work on your hands.
Did basially this over my own den last year. The surprise for me wasn't the splices, it was the grounds. Half of them were just twisted together bare with nothing on the end and one wasn't connected at all. So when you redo it, check every ground, not just the hots. Also, I screwed my new box to a little plywood block spanning between the joists instead of nailing it to the stud face. When you're pushing that many splices back in, a box that doesn't flex makes the whole job way easier. Mine had zero notes on anything, so those sharpie marks you found are a gift.
One thing to remember before you count everything out: that new fan cable you're adding counts toward the fill too. When I ran my own fan circuit last spring I nearly got the box sized right and then realized I'd forgotten the two new conductors plus ground that hadn't existed yet. Not a huge deal, but it's the difference between fitting and going up a size. On the two-box question, I'd say split it sooner rather than later if it's borderline. A 4x4 square box with a blank cover is cheap, sits flat against the stud, and gives you room to actually work in there instead of fighting your own elbows.
Been through this same cleanup in my own crawlspace junction, and the one tool that changed everything for me was a cheap non-contact voltage tester. Flipping the breaker is step one, but I ran that pen over every conductor before unwinding anything and it caught a circuit that was on a diferent breaker than I expected. Saved me a very bad afternoon. Once I knew everything was actually dead, redoing the splices took twenty minutes instead of an hour of sweaty double checking.
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required