Thanks for the ideas; I will keep them in mind. In the end, my wife spoke (it is her birthday present, after all) and requested a natural finish. You can see a picture of it after the 1st coat of Tung Oil at:
formatting link
a beginner project with plenty of beginner mistakes but if I waited to post a picture until I'd built the perfect piece then it would be a long wait. Here's a quick summary of the lessons I learned from this project:
- When you're a beginner, start by building projects from someone else's plans;
- Follow those directions exactly; don't try to get cute;
- If the size of piece B depends on the size of piece A, then wait to cut piece B until you've cut and measured piece A;
- A well-thought-out jig can really make some operations much more accurate and safe.
- Ain't no shame in using nails (for a beginner, anyway)
Dan