My house was built in 1999, and it seems that the builder was sloppy when attaching the decorative vinyl shutters (over vinyl siding). I say this because two of the shutters have fallen off over the past year, and some of the plastic screw-like fasteners on most of the remaining shutters have popped out -- it's obvious that the ends of the plastic fasteners have broken off inside the hole. It gets very windy around my house, and I suspect that has contributed significantly to the problem. I suspect that more shutters will soon be falling off.
There are a total of 10 windows on the front of the house (two of them currently missing one shutter each -- looks terrible). I want to repair the situation, but not sure what would be best...
The shutters that fell off are broken. I'm not sure if I could find an exact match to replace them (no luck at Home Depot or Lowes) -- close match, but not exact. Even if I found an exact match, I suspect there might be a noticeable color-difference (e.g., maybe the existing ones have faded with years in the sun, etc.).
At this point, I'm leaning heavily towards getting all new shutters, very similar to the existing ones (15"x60" Forest Green, like from Home Depot). My biggest question, however, is if I should attach the new shutters using the included matching-plastic screw-things, or would it perhaps be better to use something like wood screws? I'm not even sure what's behind there -- if there's wood to bite into with a screw, or what.
Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Please advise.