The Amish are back.......

Loading thread data ...

That's how evolution works. Anybody dumb enough to believe this nonsense and spend good money on this simple fan, will be deprived of his money. Thus he will be unable to buy food and perish. He will not replicate his (dumb) genes. That's how the human race gets upgraded.

We should be grateful to the Amish for providing these miracles of heating and cooling technology. :-)

Reply to
Walter R.

I think it's more than just a fan.

A newspaper ad about it I read last week makes it sound like you have to freeze some liquid filled plastic containers like the kind you'd place in with stuff in a cooler box. And then stick them inside the thing.

They nicely avoid mentioning the energy used to freeze those things in your kitchen fridge, or the space they probably take up in the freezer compartment while you're doing that.

"There's a sucker born every minute."...But according to this link, it wasn't Barnum who said that.

formatting link
Jeff

Reply to
jeff_wisnia

Nothing new, just dubious marketing for an evaporative cooler "swamp cooler" which actually works in low humidity high-heat conditions. It is notably useless in a higher humidity situation.

formatting link

Reply to
George

As George said, it's just a swamp cooler. They are very useful in some circumstances and nearly useless in others. But if it's a hot summer day and you're working in your garage, or if you are on the sidelines of a football game, they work pretty well. If you are at

100F and 95% humidity, they aren't so good.
Reply to
PatM

They should be ashamed of themselves.

Reply to
Master Tang

"gilb" wrote in news:00VYl.28973$ snipped-for-privacy@newsfe17.iad:

I find it odd that anyone would click on a post with only a link for content from an unfamiliar (to me anyway) poster.

Reply to
Red Green

A bucket of ice with a fan blowing on it might be as good. CR magazine said it might only cool a room 2 degress, not the 10 advertised. Evaporating water and raising the humidity could make you less comfortable, and the price they charge for that junk!

Reply to
ransley

Two things of note:

1) Other than a mailing address in Ohio, the web site makes no suggestion I can find of any relation to the Amish. I think the OP was making a joke about the level of technology used by this device. I would be surprised if it's not made in China.

2) It's not JUST an evaporative cooler, it also uses blocks of "ice" to absorb heat from the room. Of course, they don't mention that unless your freezer is outside it will return all that heat to the air in the kitchen, plus some extra heat from running the compressor.

Reply to
Larry The Snake Guy

Yeah, some company fraudulently using the Amish good reputation to hawk their junk. Shame on the company.

Reply to
Stormin Mormon

The "HeatSurge / Coolsurge" scam has been dicussed in here at least once before. To get an idea of the actual cooling capacity of the Coolsurge, just remember where the term "ton" comes from when used when used in the air conditioning capacity context, and then look at the plastic thing you freeze that supplies the "coolsurge". And that's not even counting the heat from the freezer that is added to the house as another poster mentioned. About like trying to cool the house by leaving the refrigerator door open. Larry

Reply to
Lp1331 1p1331

Not everyone is ate up with paranoia .

s
Reply to
Steve Barker

formatting link

Reply to
Still Just Me...

Still Just Me... wrote in news: snipped-for-privacy@4ax.com:

There are quite a number of differences.

Reply to
Mr.Spock

amish don't wear buttons? i didn't know that..

maybe i should learn things from a better source then youtube?

Reply to
Matt Lewis

Weird Al wouldn't lie to you.

Reply to
Still Just Me...

HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.