I had to turn the gas off temporarily, then turned it back on. Naturally I forgot to re-light the water heater pilot and it was off for about 18hrs. When I finally went to do that, I saw a puddle under the water heater. It was dripping from what I believe is the drain valve. It's a white plastic threaded fitting similar to the one in this pic and located in about the same place:
Why would the leak from the drain valve stop when I lit the pilot?