I work at HD.. Been there in Garden for 5 yrs. I buy what I DONT see coming back. I am the one who they call at returns when someone brings something back. The JD is obviously made by JD and is warranted through JD exclusively. The Toro, Yard Machine, MTD and Cub Cadet are made by MTD, so take it anywhere to get repaired. JD is the only "Lawn Tractor" with one piece frame from front to back, where as everything else is several pieces bolted together. With that feature alone, the deck and tractor stays level longer because you don't get the "sag" after a while where you cant keep the deck level. If you sat on both, Where were your control pedals and what do you have to do to operate the machines? The brake pedal is in the way over the motion pedal and you have to shift a lever for fwd/rev and you have to turn the key back and push a button to cut in reverse on the Toro. JD, not so much aggravation. The JD is Post delivered by a JD mechanic where as everything else is assembled by an assembly contractor at HD and Lowes. The Briggs engine is made to specs by Briggs, for JD and is pressure lubed as well. I bought a L-118 last year and I love it. 22 hp Briggs, 42" deck, high back seat and over-width rear tires to lessen compaction. As for ground engaging tools: You can "pull" anything you want that HD/Lowes stocks. Even a special order 46" pusher blade or a power 42" snow thrower on JD, Toro, and Cub Cadet. Ground engaging means pull behind plows, tillers. As for the decks, ease of removal, hidden baffles clogging up, belt/blade replacement, and finish add up to a good look. The JD is better. Ability to rebuild the front end, battery maintenance, grease points, and who will come to your house to repair are things to consider. Anyway , good hunting, but at my store we promote the "Drive-before-you-buy" aspect. Ask to drive first. That is one thing I do see at returns.."I didn't know it wouldn't do whatever so I don't want it". Well now you're screwed because before you get a refund we have to send it out for repair to see if you damaged it, and well, you know the cuss-fest that comes with that... But above all else, cutting grass should be fun!