So I've been testing various stains for my daughter's bed project. I'm finding that nobody's finish colors match, some aren't even close. Minwax Polyshades Pecan doesn't even come close to Old Master's Pecan Gel, Watco Oil Cherry doesn't come close Zar's Cherry Wiping stain. In fact, via a call to MInWax, I found out that their own Polyshades Pecan doesn't match their own Golden Pecan Wiping stain.
I know that they are all different types of finishes, but the colors with the same names are so different it's amazing.
My daughter likes the color of the MinWax Polyshades Pecan, but it needs to brushed on and I don't have the patience to brush such a large project. In the end, I found that the Zar wiping stain in Cherry comes very, very close to the Polyshades Pecan. Once it's stained, I'll decide on a wipe-on final finish.
Props to Woodcraft and a local paint store for testing a bunch of finishes for me. In the end it was the local paint store that found the best match.