There really isn't all that much risk in trying to partially renew the
finish over total refinishing. Give it a shot, it may work and if it does
you're ahead of the game. If it doesn't, well, you're back to option two
anyway and all you've lost is a little time.
As for specific recommendation, Personally I wouldn't even try to give one
without seeing the pieces up close and personal.
Click to see the full signature.