Sun, Dec 23, 2007, 5:31am (EST-3) email@example.com (Old Guy) doth sayeth:
<snip> Their power saw of choice was a miter saw. I was impressed. It's
a lot safer than a circular saw or a table saw, and the design
practically prevents kick backs. <snip>
I consider my mitre saw one of my scarier tools. I can just see
turning a bunch like those descrived with miter saws, and lopping
fingers off right and left.
It's no problem cutting along a line with a circular saw, if you
don't opt to use a straightedge. "Ge doctore, I was just trying to cut
that really small piee." Probably they wouldn't do much better with a
panel saw, proably want to cut some odd shapes. If they freehand panels
on a contractor saw they sure can't be much concerned with really
accurate cuts. I'd say the safest way would be a couple of circular
saws, and a couple (or more) dedicated cutters. Or get 'em a few sabre
saws and turn 'em loose, I've never heard of anyone getting a critical
injury with one of those - of course there's always a first time. And
make bloody damn sure they con't screw with any circular saw guards.
Me, I'd probably bail, and to Hell with 'em all.
My memory is not as sharp as it used to be. Also, my memory is not as
sharp as it used to be.
On Sat, 22 Dec 2007 17:14:25 -0800 (PST), DonkeyHody
I purchased the Milwaukee panel saw for the scene shop for our local
community theater. We used it to cut anything from 1/4 inch luan to
3/4 inch decking ply.
Not only does it make cutting full sheets of ply much easier, it's
much faster and safer than trying to wrestle those heavy sheets up
onto a table saw. Everyone who had an experience with this saw was
amazed at how much easier it was to use.
I use both the panel saw and straight edge/circular saw for cutting
plywood and can only say that when building a set with lots of plywood
cutting, the panel saw wins hands down.
Two points: Take your time on setup to get it as accurate as possible
and purchase the mid support rail. I didn't do the second and
regretted it because you have to bend down a lot when cutting narrow
strips to length.
You're the guy I've been looking for! From the photos, it appears
that the Milwaukee saw doesn't move horizontally, that you push the
material through it to make cuts longer than 4 feet, is that correct?
Is the bed long enough to rip an 8 foot piece accurately, or does it
require skill to keep it straight?
"If you think you've made it foolproof, you've obviously
underestimated the ingenuity of the fool."
On Sun, 23 Dec 2007 06:40:29 -0800 (PST), DonkeyHody
That is correct. The saw only moves vertically. I think the total
movement is The platten is rotated 90 degrees and locked in place for
long rip cuts. For full 8' sheets, you will need to buy the feed rail
extensions. For ripping, I've found it's best to have two people (but
not necessary). One to feed and one to extract. However, you can feed
a sheet part way, move to the other side and pull the sheet the rest
of the way through. I typically handled up to 1/2 inch sheets myself,
and asked for help with 3/4 inch sheets for ease of handling.
Again, accuracy depends on setup. The bottom rail extensions have
adjustable feed rollers, that need to be aligned with a long straight
edge. If I remember correctly, the feed rollers on the main rail were
pre-set. I didn't check the accuracy very often, but in general, the
accuracy appeared to be within 1/16 inch or better.
The only drawback is that the crosscut stop only goes to about 60
inches, so if you are using the stop to cut a piece longer than that,
you need to do a little math.
The picture shown here: http://tinyurl.com/35d57s includes the rail
extensions (as well as all of the other accessories, I believe).
The show choir is self-funded. It does not compete with education for
money. The director is paid a salary by the school, but ticket sales
and fundraisers bring in the rest. Oh, and the parents of each kid pay
an unholy monthly fee for the privilege of participation.
"We, the unwilling, led by the unknowing, are doing the impossible for
the ungrateful. We have done so much with so little for so long that
we are now qualified to do anything with nothing."
well, if they have the funds and the space, a panel saw would be of
great service to them. good panel saws are expensive, though. perhaps
if there is a metal shop at the school they might be interested in
taking on building one as a class project?
Simple, cheap method that works great for me:
Build open support frame of tubafors screwed together more than an inch
away from edge, to make an open matrix about 4' x 8'.
Drop 4' x 8' sheet onto frame.
Set up straight edge for cutting an edge "really" straight, if it
matters, with circ-saw set to just cut through sheet. Then set up
straight edge for subsequent cuts. Main challenge here is sequence of
cuts to harvest most of sheet. Simple factory-made guide of (2) 4'+
lengths works great.
Resting tubafore support frame on tailgate of p/u and horses also works
great for breaking down sheets while unloading, and minimizes damage.
Only incremental expense is a few tubafores and screws. Meanwhile, all
extremities are full-length. No amputations/kickbacks yet.
I think most of the posters are missing the point. The OP is asking
if a panel saw is the best solution for his situation, not the
I've used a table saw, circular saw with straight edge and home made
jigs and none of them beat the panel saw for dealing with full size
sheets of plywood. I will admit that I've never used a commercial
table saw with massive infeed and outfeed tables though.
Our scene shop workers consisted of people with many, many years of
experience to those with no experience at all. With minimal training,
just about anyone could be taught to use the panel saw safely.
I never felt comfortable letting people with little experienc use the
table saw or circular saw. I won't say it doesn't happen, but I never
experienced a kickback with the panel saw.
Another thing of note is that we have a power miter saw fixed in place
for cutting board stock. We have the luxury of having a 30 foot bench
with the saw fixed in the middle. Again, much safer and quicker than
a circular saw.
Exactly. Many, despite evidence to the contrary, also seem to have it in
their heads that experienced woodworkers are doing this work. Though it
would be nice, I have no real need for a panel saw because I just don't cut
enough volume of sheet goods to make it worth the cost. The OP talks about
cutting 40 sheets at a time.
Thank you for correctly interpreting my perhaps ill-phrased question.
I know all about the cheap solutions. Trouble is, they take too much
time and don't reduce the risk significantly. I've been cutting
plywood with a circular saw and straightedges for decades, but this
high-volume operation needs a quicker method that will yeild accurate
results and can be used by semi-skilled volunteers. I'm already
convinced that a panel saw, or some other very similar machine, is
what we need. What I wanted to know was about the Milwaukee in
particular, and also if there are other similar machines I should look
into. Thanks again for your help.
"While I know you understood what you thought I said, you fail to
realize that what you heard was not what I meant."
I admire your diplomatic approach to joining this group. No one responds well
to the "new kid on the block" trying to boss people around or becoming a
"safety Nazi"! Your skills have obviously been recognized and I'm sure you're
correct in concluding that they view you as their "technical expert".
There've been many good suggestions (some not so good) about equipment and
techniques so I'll simply add that I think a good quality panel saw would
make a fine "investment" for many years to come. May I also suggest an idea
taken from the pages of The Home Depot approach to equipment. I work parttime
at a local store and no one can operate any of the equipment (saws, cutters,
forklifts, etc.) without first completing an equipment orientation and safety
training course. Their policy is driven for liability reasons.
May I suggest that you, as the expert, develop a brief and simple orientation
course for each of the tools in the inventory. The intent wouldn't be to
teach people how to design and build things... but simply to ensure they know
the correct and safe operation of a power tool. Whoever is the overall "boss"
of the program would readily see the value of adopting a policy requiring
everyone to have this training before using any potentially dangerous power
tool. Maintaining a log showing who's been trained would be a good thing, too.
The orientation would minimize the potential for personal injury or damage to
the equipment and it would go a long way to indemnifying the organization
(and its members) from a lawsuit.
Good on 'ya for helping in the community and passing on your skills and
knowledge to the younger generation. After all... they'll be building our
One thing I failed to make clear is that these are NOT high school
kids building sets. The dads are building sets while the kids
practice. But many of the other dads are quite a bit younger than I
I'm amazed both with what they've been able to accomplish in building
sets, and with the total lack of organization or any systematic
approach. The guy who is overall in charge of making it happen is an
architech. He's mostly an artsy type with good people skills, but
he's not into tools & such. He confessed the other day that he
doesn't own a drill.
There are huge gaps in the group's tool inventory. Those gaps are
usually filled by tools the volunteers bring from home. I don't mind
taking my tools up there for my own use, or under my watch, but I
treasure my tools and I'm not willing to leave them for others to use
while I'm not there.
Most of the group had never used a quality jig saw before and were
amazed at the performance and smoothness of my Porter Cable.
There's lots of other tools I'd like them to buy besides the panel
saw, but I think the panel saw would help prevent that accident that's
just waiting to happen.
"Every man is my superior in that I can learn from him." - Thomas
I may have missed it, but are you not going to instruct them on safe tool
use? And, as soon as possible? You seem preoccupied with them buying a panel
saw, but they have they're safety hazards too, just not as many as a table
saw. Why haven't you yet spoken up within your theatre group about your
concerns about safety? Either you're too shy to do so for some reason or
hesitant for another reason. What is it? I'm not attacking you, reciting
what seems to be happening.
I did point out to them the dangers of crosscutting against the
fence. I have stated to the leadership that I think wrestling full-
size sheets across an undersize table saw with no outfeed table is
unecessarily dangerous. But until we have a better way, I'm not going
to attempt to stop grown adults from doing something just because I
consider it risky. If I were in charge of them, it would be
different, but I'm not. Next you'll want me to confront people who
skydive, bungie jump and jaywalk. I'm not taking on that
responsibility, and if you see it as a character weakness, I can live
"We should be careful to get out of an experience only the wisdom
that is in it - and stop there; lest we be like the cat that sits
on a hot stove-lid. She will never sit down on a hot stove-lid
again---and that is well; but also she will never sit down on a cold
one anymore." - Mark Twain
There's a considerable difference between people who engage in risky
activities for the thrill of it and those who are just trying to enjoy
themselves in friendly interaction like your theatre group. You didn't
hesitate for one second in stating your concern here in this newsgroup
obviously because you feel the people here would be more likely to support
what you are thinking. That doesn't appear to be the case within your
theatre group however.
If was in your place, I'd speak up and present graphic examples of what
they're doing wrong and suggest how it could be fixed. All that could happen
is that I might be temporarily booed a bit, but then it would be over.
Consider however, if they took you seriously and acted on your concerns.
Just as obviously, these are only my opinions. My personality usually
dictates that I should act if I think I can make a positive contribution to
some situation, at least when it comes to my friends.
You know, you don't always need graphic examples to get the point across.
A few kindly spoken words, suggesting that they do something different,
or rethink an action they're taking sometimes works just fine.
As long as you're trying to help, IME most people are willing to let you.
Marching to the beat of a different drum is great... unless you're in
Festool has a pretty neat setup . . . but its $$$$$.
In the recent FWW 2008 tool review they looked at a number of methods
of cutting sheet goods. Cant remember all they tested, but the
festool got high marks and the Lee Valley system did pretty well.
I hope you won't think I'm bragging when I say that I own or owned just about
every tool you can imagine. And to present my credentials I'll tell you that
I was a licensed welder, machinist and gunsmith before pursuing knowledge and
skill development in the building, electronics and computer trades. I've
owned a number of different businesses and have achieved a measure of
noteriety (within my neck of the woods, anyway) as a world champion athlete
in a shooting sport. I'm told that I'm a fairly reasonable and learned guy.
But...my suggestion to you draws upon 32 years in law enforcement (I'm
currently a Detective Sergeant in command of a specialty unit). Over the
years I've investigated many, many industrial and residential accidents and
have witnessed both the physical carnage and the legal ramifications from
these types of events. Ask your insurance agent why your homeowner's policy
includes a "slip and fall" clause to protect you in the event a trespasser
becomes injured while on your property.
North American culture... and more importantly, our courts... have created
the notion that we have a right to be protected from our own stupidity. If I
get hurt... someone else has to pay, regardless of how stupid my actions were!
If you take one of your tools to use at the jobsite and someone uses it
without your knowledge or permission and hurts themselves... in a lawsuit you
could be found "negligent" for not securing the dangerous tool from another
person's access. And it could cost 'ya.
If you take one of your tools to use at the jobsite and allow another person
to use it with your permission but without ensuring that they know how to use
it safely, and they get hurt... you could be found "grossly negligent" and it
could cost 'ya... big time! The same holds true for the organization and its
principals, directors, directly involved members, and so on.
But don't just take my word for it... check out the meaning of "negligence"
and "gross negligence" with a lawyer and ask him or her about civil liability
as well. I'm sure that the artsy fartsy architect will understand... as he's
no doubt aware of his liability risks in the event that a building he designs
should fall on someone's head.
I'm not trying to scare you... I'm offering my opinion to help you, based
upon my experience and based upon the horror stories I personally know about.
It would be a shame to lose all your tools... your house, your car/truck, etc.
for lack of a few minutes taken to cover 'yer butt!
Geez... did I say all that out loud?!? I didn't mean to climb up on a soap
box... I guess I would just hate to see a good guy like you get hooped!
All the best and good luck to you.
Message posted via CraftKB.com
On Wed, 26 Dec 2007 05:44:41 GMT, "toolman946 via CraftKB.com"
Sadly, I had some similar thoughts.
I do volunteer work, where I'll never loan my power tools to anyone
who I haven't developed total respect for their skills and
sensibilities. I turn down LOTS of requests at jobs to use my tools
to make a quick cut, or drive a few nails...
I'm not even sure I would select a specific panel saw for the school
to buy, or install it. I would simply point them to a knowledgeable
local dealer, who can sell it and set it up.
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.