I thought I'd chip in here... I have a 1960-era #5. One of the blue ones, not a Bailey pattern. It looks and feels like a pale shadow of what the glory days of Stanley must have been, and just screams "cheap" and "not made very well." (I got it for $25.)
Even with that, I can get shavings that appear to be no more than half a wood cell thick. As you said, it's all about the way it's adjusted. Takes a bit of fiddling, but if this junker can do it, any remotely decent plane can do it.
I have read that the most important part of a plane is the iron-and Ron Hock(?) makes the best. Apparently the thicker irons are MUCH better that what comes on the plane from the factory.
Well, I ordered a Veritas low angle block plane. Personnally it was between that and a low angle smoothing plane. Between my thinking and some of the comments of you that have used to low angle block plane I felt that it was the best next purchase. I tried this plane about 3 yrs ago (when it first came out) at a show and it was impressive then when I knew JACK about plane usage. I know I will appreciate it now.
Mine still have the stock irons, FWIW.
I'd like to try a thick one some day. Chatter *has* been a problem. Chatter is irritating.
I can still get ultra thin shavings out of this thing though, even with all the crappy stock parts.
HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.