Do any of the Borgs carry the Fenner Link Belts, or is this a Mailorder item?
- posted
20 years ago
Link Belts
Loading thread data ...
- Vote on answer
- posted
20 years ago
Some of your machinery supply houses sell them; probably most do. But don't buy the green ones; I ordered some Fenner ones from Grizzly as they had shown in their catalog; they sent me green ones that are nowhere nearly as good as the RED Fenner belts. But you can buy them at your local tool supply building.
- Vote on answer
- posted
20 years ago
What's wrong with the green ones? I have one on my table saw. Should I paint it red?
Remove the 'remove' in my address to e:mail me.
- Vote on answer
- posted
20 years ago
Rustoleum Red will do fine! Actually, my green belts are much more loosley woven than the Fenner. Hey, if you like it, that's great!
- Vote on answer
- posted
20 years ago
I found the best price on the genuine Fenner red ones at Harbor Freight. However, I don't think they carry it anymore. Last time I looked in their catalog they showed green belts.
FWIW, I heard the red ones *are* better. Some guy had comparisons on his website. After some use the cheaper green ones produced a powder.
Layne
- Vote on answer
- posted
20 years ago
That would be me. I have the twist-lock belts on a lot of my machinery, including my cabinet saw, which takes three "matched" belts. Everything works just fine; my cabinet saw easily passes the "nickel" test.
IME, the Accu-Link belts are not as nice as the PowerTwist brand. However, they appear to work just as well. They've been running some of my machinery for about two years now, at heavier levels of use than is typically encountered in the home-shop, although perhaps not so much as industrial-level use. I have no major complaints.
I wrote a mini-review on the belts awhile back. It's at
formatting link
the glowing praise in that write-up, I have since found that the link belts are no better than cogged v-belts in some applications, and no better than top quality ordinary v-belts in others. I learned much of this by experimentation after writing the review, but haven't gotten round to updating the page.
Cogged belts share many of the advantages of link belts: excellent vibration dampening characteristics, reduced slippage, higher energy efficiency, longer life, and resistance to taking a set.
Additionally, there is no waste, as occurs with a link belt when there is a leftover, unused portion, and which drives the already high cost of link belts up even more. On the down side, cogged belts are not adjustable, and in the event of a broken belt (exceedingly rare) the entire belt is lost, as opposed to one or a few links. Personally, I'm quite willing to give up these latter two advantages in exchange for the cost savings.
Apparently the only unchallenged advantages of the link belts are (1) the ease of replacement -- especially in cases where machinery must ordinarily be disassembled for it -- and (2) the ease of maintaining spare inventory. (Anybody, please feel free to jump in and correct me if I'm missing something here.)
While both the link belts and the cogged v-belts dampen vibration, the link belts are a little better with lower frequency vibrations such as are cause by pulley or load imbalances and such. However, both types of belt also introduce some higher frequency noise owing to their "teeth." In this respect the link belts are noticeably worse (louder in the higher
frequencies), and they also "squeak" a bit from the links rubbing against one another and the pulleys or sheaves.
Because of this, a particular machine may sound quieter or louder with the link belt than with a cogged or regular v-belt. On all my machines that run them, save one, the link belts seem as quiet or quieter than regular or cogged v-belts. The oddball is a woodworking bandsaw whose sheet metal stand apparently oscillates in harmony with the higher pitch of the link belt links. That saw runs about 3 dBA quieter with a cogged v-belt and 2 dBA quieter with a regular v-belt.
Here is some slightly dated pricing information I collected from MSC
formatting link
one of my favorite industrial suppliers. Prices for
36", 48", and 60" classic v-belts are $6.80, $8.16, and $9.35, respectively. Cogged belts in the same sizes run $8.43, $10.14, and $11.47. Assuming no waste, the same link belts would cost about $12, $16, and $20 each at Harbor Freight pricing. Something to think about.
Jim