I purchased my HF unit about a year ago, and it is clearly marked as a
20 amp motor. I couldn't believe it. It certainly sounds and sucks
like a 20 amp as well. I don't believe that they mean peak amps
either. I've never seen a motor marked as such. I've even wondered
if mine was a mistake i.e. they mounted the wrong motor!! I too have
been very pleased with mine. I've filled the bag up multiple times,
and the motor continues to purr. I recommend this unit to anyone who
will listen to me drone on.
I bought on on Friday night last week for the internet price of
$149.99 at the local store. It is quite heavy, ended up sliding it
onto my mechanics creeper to move it around in the box.
Yesterday I ordered the Wynn cartridge conversion after reading Bill
Pentz's site, I figured I would spend $40 getting new bags at least,
and the filter kit with plastic catch bags and the cartridge was about
$103.00. Being in the diesal truck industry, I appreciate how well
those big canisters work.
Wynn indicated I could just blow it out with compressed air from the
outside in, so I expect the cartridge to last me a LONG time.
I've got conflicting information on the size of the HF dust inlets.
Wynn says if I take the Y off I get a single 5" line. I see JET has a
6" and 4" adapter available for their 2hp unit, and I suspect I could
attach that to the harbor freight impeller section.
Also considering moving the motor off the bottom of the cart onto a
small chest of drawers and giving the motor to bags hose a straight
shot. Perhaps reducing it from square to round right at the bags
instead of right out of the impellar housing.
Hope to get rid of ALL the dust in my garage shop. Trying to figure
out how to move the jointer to be closer to the orientation of the
hoses. don't want to have to step over them!
I suspect HF is overrated and does not have the same capacity as the Jet,
even though they both claim 2hp. One rough comparison is to look at impeller
size. I believe the Jet 2hp uses a 12 inch impeller.
I would rate the HF unit at 1-1/2 HP, more closely relates to Jets 1-1/2 HP
unit, the DC1100A which Amazon has for $330!
Is the Jet better? Probably! Is it worth over twice the price? I don't
believe so. At least not for the hobby wood dorker. You can get the HF unit
for $159 pretty much any time. Plus the often run coupons for $10 on
puchaces over $100 to get the out the door price to $149. Better bags can be
had cheap enough so it is still a good deal.
On 2 Nov 2004 18:35:44 -0800, email@example.com (Alan W)
I'll have to wait until I can afford to get one, look at it, then
re-read your post... (I print a lot of this NG out)
I got lost on the cartridge conversion and quit reading somewhere
around taking the Y off and the 4" and 6" inch thing... like trying to
understand someone talking about a car when you've never seen one..
I was noticing tonight that almost an hour after sanding a couple of
boards with the palm sander, I could see dust in the air when my wife
came in the driveway with the lights on... HAS to be bad for me,
breathing in that crap every evening..
Unfortunately, the dust collector will do very little to help that (I
have yet to see a palm sander connected to a dust collector). What you
need for the fine floating dust is a dust filtration unit. Lots of old
posts on this and the argument between those who recommend buying a
commercial unit and those who (like me) built theirs from a furnace
blower and some good filters. So now not only are you hearing about a
car without seeing one, we've thrown in motorcycles ;)
Here's another link that has some more info on the subject. I'm trying to
learn about this as well. As far as actually breathing in the dust goes, I
think that I'd be wearing a dust mask.
On 3 Nov 2004 08:27:45 -0800, firstname.lastname@example.org (David Hall) wrote:
I actually understand that one and agree, Dave...
I'll probably copy Ken Vaughn's system, as it seems very efficient and
looks like the construction is within my skill level..
I had forgotten the a dust collector doesn't filter dust unless it's
fed into it... I might need the filter system more than the DC!
email@example.com (Alan W) wrote in message
While it sounds like this unit will pick up the big stuff, I doubt
it'll get the really fine dust. The stuff that will clog up your
lungs. If you really want to get ALL of the dust as you say, check
out this site for some info:
Like the fine dust produced from sanding? Which you probably will not be
able to make use of your dust collector while doing?!
If you want to get all the fine dust it takes quite a commitment, connect
all your tools, overarm collector for your tablesaw, downdraft sanding
table, and on and on! Way out of range for most hobbyists!
firstname.lastname@example.org (Alan W) wrote in message
The dust collector is assembled and awaiting the cartridge. I am
going to try 5" line from the single port on the impellar housing
I took the housing apart tonight and measured the actual diameter of
the impellar to be 10", photo here:
Jet is supposed to be 11", but short of measuring one. The cavity in
the housing would certainly take a larger impellar.
On 5 Nov 2004 22:58:58 -0800, email@example.com (Alan W)
Wow! beefier than I expected at that price... but I've never seen or
priced one before, either...
You're not even going to try it as it comes from HF, so you can see
the improvement with the adapter and cartridge?
Nope, those 30 micron bags give me the jeebies. I still have quite a
bit of work to do even after I get the cartridge and assemble it onto
the DC. My local hose supplier was out of 5" DC hose and had none on
order. There was another local source.
Since I have moved my jointer and the tablesaw to be in a T arrangement,
the amount of hose I need is quite a bit less. Going to figure out how
to run some line down to my router insert on the tablesaw without having
it all over the floor, or ugly ugly up on the ceiling.
ok, now you've got me worried (again)
I started this post and was surprised at how many people in the wreck
use the HF collector...
now, it seems that a lot of folks are saying that it needs a better
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.