Hello all,
Well, it's time to finally buy a dovetail jig. I've narrowed it down to the Leigh D4R and the Porter Cable 24" Omnijig model 77240. I need the variable spacing and the 24" width.
I've searched the archives and read all that has been written so far. It has been a while since this has been discussed and was hoping someone has something new to add, some real hands on experience with both jigs and can speak from experience. I keep waiting for one of the woodworking mags to do a detailed comparison and am surprised that they have not yet.
So, following are some questions I had. Any help would be appreciated.
Thanks, Larry
Any comments on any of these issues/features? :
- First, my overall impression of the two jigs: Both are functionally the same. The Omnijig is built like a tank, but the machining and manufacturing tolerances are less precise than the D4R. I have read a few comments about the finger-template-bar being seriously bowed and also about a height mismatch or step between the finger template and the stabilizer bar causing the router to not sit level. The D4R is more precisely made though perhaps a bit more delicate. Any truth to these impressions?
- The Omnijig bit depth gage and template positioning stops - Are these really accurate enough so that, once dialed in, test cuts are unnecessary. Or, are they almost close enough and therefore just a gimmick?
- Clamping systems: The Omnijig looks nice?
- Dust collection ?
- Available bits: Omnijig uses 1/2 shank bits, the D4R uses 8mm. Does either system have more or fewer bits available (width, depth and dovetail angle)?
- How does the selection of available bits affect the look of the finished dovetails?
- Router stability?
- Do either of the jigs have any great, must have features or any annoying or deal-breaking features?