...has anybody used the Pinnacle Honing Guide from Woodcraft?
As for the paper clogging up quickly, I had trouble with that in the beginning. I was being too conservative with the amount of paper I would use and I would press too hard and take off too much metal, especially with the finer grits. The paper would get clooged quickly and frustration levels increased. I don't know if this is the right thing to do or not but I squirt a little 3-in-1 or, sometimes, some mineral spirts on the wet-dry paper and the whole process seems to work both better and faster. I makes sense to me because, if I think of it, we would use mineral spirits with the wet-dry paper when we would get our rust bucket cars ready to paint....
Anyway, I am interested if anybody has used or seen the honing guide. I currently use the Veritas I with somewhat mixed results. I have the funny feeling it is because of the single pressure point and my stupid heavy hand. Whatever I am sharpening always seems to get out of whack eventually. The Pinnacle say there is no way you can do this but I am sure if anybody can, I can!