I need about 100M of 25x250 fascia boards and they are working out quite expensive. What are the problems if I decides to cut fascia boards from
2400 x 1200mm sheets of 25mm MDF?
Also are there any advantages in using MDF primer as opposed to normal wood primer?
Thanks, Brian
Didn't find your answer? Ask the community — no account required.
D
Dave Plowman (News)
MDF doesn't like water. A decent ply would be better. Or even PVC.
S
Steve Firth
MDF is essentially thick cardboard. So umm what do you think will happen when it rains?
T
The Medway Handyman
MDF is basically Wheatabix. Don't even think about it. uPVC.
B
Bolted
Exterior MDF would last a while. Normal or MR would die pretty quickly
T
The Medway Handyman
Didn't know they made that? Never seen it in the sheds.
B
Bolted
All sorts of things exist that they don't sell in sheds. ;)
Click on MDF:
formatting link
isn't nearly as cheap though.
formatting link
D
Dave Plowman (News)
If it's anything like exterior grade chipboard, I still wouldn't bother. ;-)
C
Cash
Quick deterioration of the MDF leading to early renewal - thus dramatically cutting any cost savings over tanalised or untreated timber [1].
None, the stuff will still rot or break down early.
[1] I have just finished painting my 30+ year old tanalised fascia boards and there was absolutely no sign of rot or decay in them - and that's a 'life' that you will *never* obtain with any type of MDF when used externally.
My advice is to 'bite the bullet' and pay the costs for some decent, treated timber and then decorate it correctly - or replace (or cover) the old stuff with plastic.
Cash
S
Stuart Noble
ISTR in Scandinavia an external grade MDF is used for road signs.
D
Dave Plowman (News)
Permanent ones? I suppose if it was coated with some high tech stuff it could be ok - but house paint isn't high tech. ;-)
B
Bolted
=A0 London SW
I don't know why you are quite so sceptical - I can understand some scepticism, but if they use a fully waterproof glue (and enough if it), why should it last any less well than WBP ply providing it isn't particularly stressed? They may well treat the sawdust with preservative (I know Medite are developing one with acetylised wood - dust equivalent of Accoya). They might even use durable hardwood dust, but I doubt it. It's a resin panel, with a cellulose filler is all. If the resin is right, and the quantity of it is right, and the filler is right, I see no reason there will necessarily be an issue. How much would you worry about leaving a sheet of compact grade laminate (commonly used for cladding - have a peek over at the new blue Royal Holloway!), or tufnol outside?
T
The Medway Handyman
<
<me9
Would last longer than the ali ones round here -- no scrap value for the pikeys.
D
Dave Plowman (News)
Experience of this sort of thing claiming to be waterproof? Of course a road sign is by nature well ventilated.
Maybe - but them they're likely more expensive to make than a decent marine ply - so rather pointless.
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required
Report Content
You are reporting this content to the moderators. They will look at it
ASAP.