Freesat aerial

Sep 02, 2013 80 Replies

Fredxx wrote: [snip]

Look up, I cited the source.

No, I'm not. They are referred to as satellite antennae[1] check out the Raytheon and Viasat sites if you don't believe me.

formatting link
formatting link

But please continue to argue, its mildly amusing to me.

[1] that's "aerial" to we Brits.

I have and it doesn't exist.

Yep - No mention of aerials in either of those two pages.

Well I will say he and his firm are one of the best if not the most competent aerial installer firms in the UK and thats after tidying up after some of them myself over time;!...

And a very interesting website too!...

formatting link

This ones quite impressive an installation for TV reception of a distant transmitter at one of the most powerful and well known transmitter sites in the country;)...

formatting link

Don't call people "morons" just because they talk differently than you.

That's complete and utter bollocks.

Which bit of "aerial" is interchangeable with "antenna" do you not understand?

Oh look a fool who makes unmarked edits to quoted text.

Don't tell me what to call morons.

tony sayer wrote: [snip]

Had I wanted an aerial installer they may have been in the running - right up until someone proved he was a pompous bell-end. However all I wanted was an opinion about the wisdom of attaching an aerial to a downspout, not a lesson from someone about a subject I know enough about already. I built my first UHF aerial when I was 13 and I really don't want or need help with something as simple as pointing a satellite aerial at the sky. Or indeed the Sky.

Then provide a link to an article by the IEEE that proves your assertion. I know you can't.

Only in your mind.

Yes my apologies, I should have made the correction more obvious.

Nah, you'll wire it to a patress faceplate.

Are you suggesting that manufacturers of such items accurately produce paraboloids rather than part-spherical surfaces?

Any reason why they can't at least try to make proper parabolas?

None whatsoever, they're made by pressing or otherwise making the dish follow the shape of a former, and it's no harder to make the dish the correct shape than the wrong one. It is slightly harder to make the former the right shape, as it requires the maker of it to give a d@mn....

What gives you reason to think they are not, at least within the bounds of manufacturing accuracy?

Don't be put off by the diminutive size of the infamous "mini-dish", it is simply a section of a parabola,

Think of it like this. Make a 'proper' parabola. Put your LNB at the focus but 'point' it at a particular area of the curve surface. Cut the rest of the surface away. Tilt the new shape to improve the signal. You've now got an offset 'dish'.

The new dish isn't as efficient as the original but it is more compact, has less wind resistance, ....

The Sky 'mini-dish' can be prone to marginal signals, in particular problems with signals when it rains. We have problems with ours and plan to increase the dish size.

If you must, but I will have to stop you if you start calling it a "receptacle".

True, but as Ian Jackson pointed out "aerial" is, or at least was, also used in the USA.

From where I'm sitting it's you that is being pompous.

In spite of an awkward interchange of views, Bill was magnanimous enough to make a kind offer of free advice, I suspect it was triggered by you mentioning you lived in a listed building.

Bill once mentioned here, or perhaps I read it on his site, an extremely invective use of a waste pipe in an aerial installation. obvious once you see it, but most people wouldn't have thought of it.

Perhaps he had something similar up his sleeve? You will never know.

Perhaps you could disguise the aerial as your trademark tin of Birds custard?

Tony, we spent last week in this 16c Grade II place in Chatsworth.

Looks like there is a BTS and backhaul dish, a 5GHz link and a couple of VHF verticals. Possibly other stuff that you might know.

formatting link

In article , Graham. scribeth thus

Yes a wi-fi distro 2.4/5.8 system by the look of it with differing makes of equipment and differing ages of same. Yes it is possible with a bit of care to get an install on a historic listed building whatever, but its not done at standard Sky install rates;!...

In article , Graham. scribeth thus

Well male for a plug and err .. female for a socket have always been easy to remember .. seems logical somewhere or 't the other;)..

formatting link

The government website uses the word "antenna" to include dishes.

Robert

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required