Does anyone have experience, hopefully positive, using systemics on orchids? I am at my wit's end spraying Neem and insecticidal soaps for scale. Now mealies are beginning to show up as well. Getting very close to making a large trip to the compost heap (if the snow ever melts) and going back to ferns and begonias. Most of the problem children are phals potted in either soil-less mixes or moss. I suspect no systemic would work in a bark mix. I have a fairly old (20+ years) can of DiSyston granules(Disulfoton Diethyl ethyl phosphordithicate) that I've used on other soil based plants with some success. Cannot find any indication of use for orchids and there isn't much on the web. From what I've found, it may even be banned in some places. Not sure what else may be available, but I'm hoping something works. Appreciate any input anyone has.
Systemic pest killers
Mar 16, 2007
Last reply: 19 years ago
14 Replies
I don't know if I'd use a chemical that was over 20 years old... let's see Was Reagan in office then??
Anyway, I've used Orthene and the newer breeds of insecticide like some of the Bayer products with imicloprid (not a systemic) in them.
But interestingly I used insecticidal soap to get rid of mealies that were invading the Paphs in my collection. Go figure. Worked for me but didn't work for you. But then I tend to hit things hard with the biggest gun I can find. (Orthene or Malathion) so maybe its not crazy that something simple would work. since the bugs in my collection probably hadn't had exposure to that insecticide.
If you can find Orthene use it. or malathion, water the day before in order to limit sequelae to the plant, cytotoxologic effects, like streaks/color break in flower buds. Won't stop them but will lessen them.
K Barrett
Dayton: Liquid Sevin is pretty effective for both scale and mealies, at recommended label rates. Mavrik (mentioned in another post) didn't seem to do much, around here. Cygon (if it's still around) will work, but does cause a lot of malformations, in my experience. For anything else that I know of, you'll have to read labels and make your own judgments about mixing. Orthene WP 75 (the 75 being the percentage of active ingredient) was my fav for many years. It worked _very_ well, but is no longer available around here. The active ingredient was acephate. The Orthene Fire Ant powders still out there are pretty much the same thing, except that the active ingredient is reduced (and I'm told it's illegal, at least in the US, to mix stronger, so as to get back to the 75%).
The Sevin and acephate, if properly applied (all over the plant, including lower leaf surfaces) DO work in bark and other "chunky" mixes, but it does take time. If you go with an acephate product or the Liquid Sevin, you need to spray once a week for 3 weeks. [I _wish_ I had a 1-time cure ...]. Otherwise, the pests will recur, and be more resistant the next time around.
To the extent possible (which I know depends on the number of plants at issue), the toothbrush (also previously mentioned by another poster) along with alcohol, soap or oil (if your conditions are not too hot for the latter), is also a very good idea. At minimum, it will get rid of the dead pests so you don't have to keep checking the same areas for re-infestation. It also provides a faster "knockdown" than you can get with any systemic I know of.
Seriously-infested plants will also benefit from repotting, for which the major season is approaching. Hope this helps, Kenni
Thanks. The biggest problem in spraying is that the plants are in a closed room under flourescent and HID lights so ventilation is a real problem during the winter (Maine where the low was -15° last week). That's why I tried the Neem, it being a natural product. Will try some of the others, which I have all of for outdoor work, when I can open the windows or take the plants outside. Was hoping that there might be a magic bullet because the scale problem has been going on for a couple of years. Every time I think they're gone, I turn around and they're back.
I recently had an infestation of mites. I talked to Jerry Fischer at Orchids Ltd. and he said to use insecticidal soap three times three days apart on all plants in the growing area. The problem seems greatly diminished, if not gone.
I will spray all the plants before bringing them in next fall.
Others have said just spraying mites with water is effective. I like the soap. I want them dead.
Regarding the inside insects, put 3 quarts of water in a gallon container, add one pint of alcohol and one pint of orange 409. Spray weekly.
I was at an Orchid class recently and one of the speaker/vendors announced that he had some plants with that he would no longer sell. He offered to show all who wanted to see why. The plants were in clear plastic pots. He had dropped one and when he picked it up and checked it for breakage he noticed mealy bug larva on many of the roots. Sprays won't kill those. unpotting, dipping and repotting will, but I wonder about the eggs.... Are they laid topside or down around the roots as well?
Bob
I don't order online anymore after several disappointing experiences. Would Home Depot carry Orange 409 and the soaps? I know they carry the usual insecticides.
I had cactus infested with root mealys about 10 years ago. I soaked them, in their pots, in Malathion and covered them with a plastic sheet for 24 hours to hold the fumes in. I did this a week apart for several weeks. It got them all. But now they may be resistant to Malathion. I believe the eggs are laid in the soil around the roots.
I don't know about Home Depot but you could check Wallgreens or Ace or others like grocers, hardware, ect.
Bob
I found this while researching a different topic:
From
formatting link
scroll down to this story:
Root Mealybugs
Arnold H. Hara, snipped-for-privacy@hawaii.edu CTAHR Dept. of Entomology, Hilo
Root mealybugs occur only on roots of their host plants. Because they are undetected, occurring below-ground, root mealybugs can be a serious pest. Currently, the Hawaiian Islands have 7 species of root or hypogaeic mealybugs. The most pestiferous species have been the coffee root mealybug, Geococcus coffeae, and Rhizoecus hibisci. Plant host range of these root mealybugs are very wide, infesting grasses, palms, citrus, cyperus, pineapple, coffee, mango and syngonium.
In pots, root mealybugs occur throughout the root mass; however, they are concentrated between the root-ball and the pot. Infestations of root mealybugs are noticeable only if the root-ball is removed from the pot. The white waxy material is the most important sign of root mealybug infestation. Mealybugs secrete lots of white waxy material that covers their bodies. Female mealybugs lay eggs or give birth to live young (crawlers).If eggs are laid, they usually hatch in less than 24 hours. Crawlers are the dispersal stage and are highly mobile. Once the crawlers find a suitable site, they settle down and begin to feed on roots with their sucking mouthparts. The entire life cycle ranges from 2-4 months depending on the species. Adults live from 27-57 days, also depending on species.
Prevention
Because the root mealybug is very difficult to control, every effort should be made to prevent spread and establishment. The following practices are recommended to prevent spread and establishment:
1.. Inspect roots of newly purchased plants for root mealybugs by removing the pot.2.. Avoid root-bound plants by re-potting as needed; root-bound plants encourage mealybugs.
3.. Use clean pots and media; if infested wash with soap and water.4.. Treat or remove infested plant hosts from your premises.
5.. Do not allow water from infested areas to drain into clean areas; crawlers can be transported in water.Control
Research by the University of Hawaii, CTAHR, has demonstrated that insecticides and/or a hot water dip are effective treatments. Dursban WP applied as a liquid drench and Marathon G are effective against root mealybug. Watering plants prior to drench application will significantly reduce problems with phytotoxicity. Consult the Cooperative Extension Service, Hawaii Department of Agriculture or a reputable agrochemical professional for a specific product registered for use. Submerging potted Rhapis palms in 120° F (49° C) hot water until the internal root ball temperature reaches 115° F(46° C) is 100% effective in killing root mealybugs. Hot water at 120° F does not significantly affect potted Rhapispalms.
For more information or a detailed report contact Arnold Hara in Hilo at Ph: (808) 974-4105, Fax: (808) 974-4110 or e-mail: snipped-for-privacy@hawaii.edu.
begin 666 bullet.gif M1TE&.#EA%0`+`+,``*NHV/KZ_=33ZY:3S^SK]O3T^N7D\\S+Z"$;F7AUP7)N MO]W<\-#/ZEM6M+:TWO___R'Y! ``````+ `````5``L```0^\,E)J[WXDM;& M*=GE(&23.$L03DZBO$HR. *A8L$B[#SC+[:5D!(@$ Q(`Z%PPQ <`(#C8 `)
*![.%=<B]1 ``.P`` ` endOur local Home depot's, Ace Hardware stores, feed and seed (like Tractor supply, TSC) and all the organic garden stores carry inseciticidal soaps, usually the brand called Safer.
FWIW, I find that so-called "insecticidal soaps" offer no advantage over ordinary household liquid dishwashing detergents, and the same might be said for horticultural oils compared to vegetable cooking oils.
My preferred spray for spot treatments is a tablespoon each of cooking oil and liquid dishwashing soap (I use a brand made from 100% vegetable and fruit oils) in a quart of water.
Wouldn't that leave the plants a sticky oily mess?
At that concentration, it doesn't. And it really does work.
Diana
Hi there Pat, I was just going to ask if there were any new better weapons. I have been fighting a losing battle here in my two greenhouses, trying everything & for the last two years, Enstar & Mavrik the choice. Lots of $$$$ & for a while I thought I had them beat both mealies & soft scale. (Includes newly repotted plants)
Instead of just spraying, I started a special routine, a section in the g/h at a time. Just finished yesterday. A sort of production line.
- Sprayed visible bugs with alcohol. Scrubbed ridges in pseudos with tooth brush.
- Dipped the entire plant & pot in the Enstar/Mavrik solution. (Growth inhibitor/Contact killer)
- Sprayed with a Neem Oil solution afterwards.
It took me 9 days to do the entire g/h & then I have to start spraying again to complete the Enstar/Mavrik regimen. I have tried everything in the past, tag plants with date etc, isolate & clean down to bear bones & still the bugs returen!!!
My point is, you jarred my train of thought here..........what do growers of thousands use. I think they throw them away & write off the loss.
I will not be using the &&&&& stuff & wondering Imicloprid is?
Got potting to do. Cheers Wendy
I found mealies in huge amounts growing on grass (big bluestem, I think) under my benches. Yes, I have grass growing under some of my benches along with the oxalis and jewel-weed, you got a problem with that? *grin*
Hopefully I can get the plants outside this summer and excercise my herbicidal tendencies.
Nicotine smoke bombs perhaps?
>Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required