water heater

Sep 15, 2026 Last reply: 1 hour ago 5 Replies

I bought a house in Florida a couple months ago. During inspection it was noticed the water heater pan had water and rust in it. We added it to the list of things to be repaired but negotiations ultimately excluded that item. This is a AO Smith Signature Series 900 Hybrid water heater. That means it's electric and also has a heat pump.



During the past couple months I noticed the leaking of water is actually coming from the pressure relief valve so I put a bucket under the pipe and caught it instead. I've also noticed the digital display occassionaly flashes ECC 1200. I called the home warranty company and they sent a plumber out. The plumber told me the water heater is only



4 years old and still under manufacturer warranty so I have to go through them. He did however drain and flush the water heater to change out the pressure relief valve.

I called the manufacturer and they authorized a replacement, but installation is on me. I had to go to Lowe's for the warranty replacement and talk to a supervisor. They want me to return the old one first before they give me a replacement, which was ridiculous to me. That meant the plumber would have to come twice, once to remove the old water heater and once to install the new one. They gave me the option of buying a new one and reimbursing me when I brought the old one back so I had to settle for that.



I chose to purchase a regular electric water heater rather than a hybrid one. I'm not a fan of new technology and prefer the old tried and true methods. The plumber arrives today to replace the water heater and install an expansion tank which the old one lacked, leading to the leaking pressure relief valve.


4 years - that's terrible, by anyone's standards. Mine has been dribbling a small leak from the pressure relief for over a year now .. one of these days I'll learn not to procrastinate .. :-) It's a 2013 Bradford-White - I'll need to look for a non-USA manufacturer when I replace it. ... a couple years ago I'd be proud to Buy USA .. .. sad situation - but .. elbows up doncha know. John T.
[snip]

I've seen that issue increasing over the past couple of decades.

The problem, so to speak, is that the expanding hot water "used to" simply push back the cold water in the pipe coming in from the street.

With modern (half century, more or less, depending on your area and the professionalism of the original plumbers) requirements of "anti backflow valves", that ain't happening anymore...

Tough to hear this. Mine is a couple of years above warranty and I expect it to go sometimes in the near future. They do not last as long with my well water. In the past I dealt with plumber who would replace under warranty but charge to install the new one. From your story I would avoid Lowes if I need a new one.

The replacement of the water heater went fine today. The guy was done in less than two hours. We both placed the old water heater in his van and he delivered it to Lowe's parking lot where then I took it inside to deal with paperwork.

Lowe's determined the original hybrid water heater cost of $1906.94 which they issued an in-store credit card for that amount. Next they refunded me the cost of the new electric water heater which I bought at $571.45. Next they debited the new water heater from the in-store credit card and I was left with a credit of $1355.49. The plumber's fee for installation was $811.00. I wish I could have paid the plumber from that money.

The cost of the plumber seems outrageous, but it was the cheapest one I could find from five estimates. This is Naples, FL and EVERYTHING is expensive here.

I would hope the AO Smith heat pump has a better service life

than the bigbox store dehumidifiers.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required