Shovel Recommendations

On 12/11/2016 7:31 AM, Stormin' Norman wrote: ...

...

No shovel is going to take that kind of abuse albeit I do think quality of wooden handle stock is significantly less than what it once was...

For the purpose you're using it for, I'd suggest replacing the handle of one of the ones you've broken with metal bar/pipe.

Why not replace the handles? Some stores carry them but you may have to do some digging or have them special ordered. We used to have a handle factory the next town over and they can fit anything for you. I used to break my splitting maul most every year.

You may even find a fiberglass handle that will outlast 10 wooden ones.

Can you replace a wooden handle with something you make?

Can you replace a fiberglass handle with something you make?

'nuff sed....

Wanna know about axes? Look fer Wranglestar on Youtube. ;)

nb

The company has been replacing the shovels we have broken. I am simply looking for a better shovel, one that will take greater punishment. In the past, it seemed we could punish the shovels with hickory handles far more than we can punish these. It is possible the older shovels were made with old growth hickory.

As for fiberglass, we have shattered at least one fiberglass handle, it didn't seem to take as much punishment as the wood handles.

Do you have experience with a specific brand of fiberglass handle shovel that you feel was superior to other shovels you have used?

Not really "'nuff sed", would you elaborate further?

No interest in axes, but thanks.

Thanks for the reply.

Have you actually purchased one of these? We acquired one and bent the blade almost immediately.

Great links - I think we have a winner ! I just can't imagine using the 8 pound all-steel model for very long .. John T.

We bent the blade, within a week, on the Bully shovel posted above.

Don't see a name and the handle on my maul is over 20 years now. After much abuse it keeps on going. Same handle is used on axes on fire trucks.

The article mentions the next-model-up which has thicker guage steel for the blade - at 1 pound extra weight. .. or go to the all-steel 8 pound $ 120. unit - if you are only using it for those occasional short tough jobs. John T.

Some cut.

If expensive means good:

I haven't tried any. We go down to the local farm supply store and buy shovels with fiber glass handles. They're not indestructible.

I don't know if these are what you are looking for:

I would also spend some time on Youtube researching shovels. I bet Wranglestar (a homesteader with $$$$) would be of some help.

nb

I don't have a recommendation for a specific shovel, but I will say the ones with fiberglass handles hold up a lot better.

Over the years we have dug a lot of trenches on our property for power lines, water lines, drain lines, etc. Not to mention general digging in the garden, or preparing for foundations.

The first few years I must have gone through a half dozen wood handled shovels. The blade holds up fine, but the wood handles always broke trying to pry out a rock or root. I wasn't applying that much pressure when they broke either.

I finally spent a little more and got a shovel with a fiberglass handle (from the local home center) and it has lasted me over 25+ years. In the last year or two the very tip of the shovel has started to bend, making it harder to dig into firm soil. So far I've been able to straighten it out again with a hammer and it's good to go for another summer. But at some point it's going to get too weak and I'll have to replace the shovel.

Good luck,

Anthony Watson

Stormin' Norman posted for all of us...

Replace the handle with fiberglass.

thanks, I will have to take another look at fiberglass handles.