Roots in or out?

Apr 19, 2009 7 Replies

I'm digging in the front yard. The park management wants me to move the little two wheel trailer from the side yard to the driveway. This means expanding the driveway the size of one space.



Problem is, the space is near a tree, and there are a lot of roots. Should I take the roots out with axe and sawzall (some up to 4 inch diameter). Or leave the roots in, and let the gravel settle around the roots?


It depends on how many roots and how close to the tree. Don't laugh but I cut some tree roots to put in a sidewalk. The sidewalk was about three or four feet from the trunk of the tree. About five years later the damn tree had fallen over and was leaning against my deck railing. It fell away from where the roots were cut. My tree was about eight to ten inches in dia. Good luck.

G.S.

If the only thing that will ever be there is the trailer, and it isn't heavily loaded, I'd let the roots be. Too much risk of killing the tree, otherwise. Since you said 'park', I'm assuming it is their tree, not yours. No overflow parking out back somewhere where you can leave the trailer when not in use? (With a suitable lock on the hitch, of course...)

-- aem sends...

And what kind of tree. I cut 6-8 inch roots off one side of a

100yr old swamp maple with no ill effects. I wouldn't try it with an oak or pine tree in my part of the world.

Ask a local arborist- or try your local extension office.

Jim

That's sobering thought. "away" is my neighbor on the other side. I don't much like him, anyway.

I don't know if the park has a back lot, but it's a good idea. I'm going to call, tomorrow, and see what the park says about the roots. They might know.

Very well worded. "cant", one of the def'n is tilt, or slope. "the tree cants a bit to the left". Not sure what it is, but it's not pine.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required