I need to replace my water heater, and my options have boiled down to
two: Home Depot has a 12-yr warranteed, GE 40 gallon natural gas heater
for $380, which I would install with my dad; or a local plumber (whom I
trust) will install a Bradford-White for $900 (same specs). I've heard
a few pretty good things about Bradford-White, but are they really that
much better than GE? Any thoughts would be helpful.
I can't tell you which is better but if they're the same specs, then I would
imagine they are pretty similar in quality.
Here's a site that may help you choose:
No worries Paul. I haven't delved too much into the link myself but figure
I will. I've got a 12 year old gas water heater that I know will probably
go south on the coldest day of the year! I do remember they recommend
buying something like a 6 year model and upgrading with their anodes
etc..... Of course they are there to make some cash but some of what they
said makes some pretty good sense. I think one item to look for, which
most brochures don't tell you, is the insulation R value that is used. The
higher the better obviously. Good luck with it!
Hey James, as it turned out, the leak was simply coming from the pipes
above my water heater, and let the water drip down the middle of the
water heater, out the bottom. When I started catching the water
dripping from teh pipe, there was no more leaking at the bottom. And
so 15 bucks worth of pipe will fix this, instead of 300 or more for a
new water heater. In the event, however, of needing a new heater, I've
decided to go with a 12-year heater. I get a heater replaced if it
goes bad up through 12 years (at least the GE ones at Home Depot are
like this--that's what the HD folks are telling me over the phone).
Plus, you save on the gas bill, so I'd rather shell out an extra 80
bucks or so and get that back over the life of the heater, than save 80
just to get a new one 6 years from now. Anyways, thanks again for the
links. I'm glad I found out the real cause!
The only diference between water heaters according to consumer reports, is
the price and the amount of insulation.
If you buy a cheap heater, but an extra insulating blanket for $12.99 for
it, you can save $600.
No water heaters last all that long, they all have to be replaced. Most of
the time you can get by with draining the scale out of it, although that
doesn't hurt anything, and either knocking the scale off the elements or
replacing them....this should make your heater last about 15-25 years.
It's an absolute waste of money paying more than $200 for a heater.
Heaters are like cars, there is no correlation between price, size and
The best cars in the world are smaller, japanese cars that are cheaper than
the largest biggest ones for example. It's all marketing and hype, and
water heaters is the same.
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.