I just pulled a toilet from our basement bathroom. The closet flange
was in a floor drain and supported by a 1 1/2" piece of wood (YUK!). I
can float some cement on the floor to make it level but I can't seem to
find a flange that will fit a 5" drain. The old one had some kind of
fiber material to make it tight but I want to replace it with a shorter
ABS flange. Any suggestions?