2 builders disagree... one says if I switch over to high effiency water
heater I can vent out side wall.. and can do away with central chimney
running up house. (already switched to HE furnace, it vents outside
house, from what I am told it no longer uses chimney)
Other builder says he thinks chimney has to stay even if I go to HE
Makes a big difference in what we can do with remodel floor plan
Who is right?
| 2 builders disagree... one says if I switch over to high effiency water
| heater I can vent out side wall.. and can do away with central chimney
| running up house. (already switched to HE furnace, it vents outside
| house, from what I am told it no longer uses chimney)
| Other builder says he thinks chimney has to stay even if I go to HE
| water heater.
| Makes a big difference in what we can do with remodel floor plan
| Who is right?
AFAIK, there is no HE electric water heater, so, you must be asking about a gas fired HE. I have one like this and all it needs is a PVC (?) pipe to the outside and a fan on the outlet.
I closed off my furnace flue when I redid the shingles.
many but not all dont require a chimney.
do realize the thru the wall vent type dont heat in a power failure.you
would need to add a big UPS. the hot water in the tank will remain hot
till used but in a power faiure it wouldnt be replaced.
getting rid of the chimney is a good idea, elminates maintence on
chimney and in cold climates does away with that BIG heat loss of the
chimney drawing heated basement air out 24 / 7
Were planning on a new 90+ furnace and high efficency hot water tank
with thru the wall vent hopefully this summer
I have a Ruud "direct vent" 50 gallon water heater which takes in inlet air
and vents exhaust directly thru the wall and requires no electrical power
for operation. This type has to be located within about 18" of an outside
Wow, you are a bit cranky.. 5 of 6 responders to my question were able
to cull enough data out of my post to give thoughtful, and helpful
answers. (it was a simple question really... do the make hot water
heaters (implied gas) that operate without chimneys.) Thanks to them
for the answer.. as to you, go take a nap... maybe you'll feel better
in with some sleep..... Geeeeez
Oh, sorry.. didn't answer your questions:
Yes, in fact I am bit daft... sort of "pleasantly demented"
No, I am not a Troll, although I know a guy named "troll" he is the
athletic trainer down at the high school... very good guy.
There are two types--direct vent and power vent. The former, as its
name suggests, vents directly to the outside via PVC pipe. There may or
may not be a fan at the outlet. The distance from the water heater to
the output is limited, usually not more than 4-6 feet, depending on
local code. The latter type uses a fan mounted on top of the water
heater, and also vents to the outside via PVC pipe. With power vent the
run can be longer, but is also dictated by local code. There are also
restrictions for both types as to where the vent is located. Where I
live, in SE Wisconsin, it must be no closer than 4 feet from a window or
door, for example. I don't see why you should be required to vent into
If you are using the original chimney that a gas furnace was disconnected
from, then you absolutely MUST get a high efficiency gas water heater vented
through the wall AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. If you read the furnace installation
instructions, it should warn you about the possibility of your chimney
falling apart. This is because now you don't have enough heat to keep it
by chimney I mean a metal tube running up & out the roof... not a
masonary one. Would something like this be an issue with a metal
"chimney" Maybe I am using the incorrect word, maybe a chimney is only
supposed to be masonary... but this is in fact metal insulated ducting.
They're commonly called a metal chimney or flue. A masonry chimney can fall
apart if it isn't kept dry. An approved metal chimney should not fall apart,
but there is a strong possibility of not having enough draft when a metal
chimney is much larger than the water heater's vent pipe. Has anyone
experienced headaches or been light-headed since the old furnace was
Bradford White "Through-the-wall gas water heater" is one brand name. There
are two in my recently-built house one up and one down to minimize hot water
waste though pipe runs. Both have worked without problems for 3+ years now
and both have forced air vents through the house walls. One has an exhaust
run of about 20 feet. The "Energy Guide" sticker that came on the heater
says it uses 238 therms a year from a range of similar heaters that use from
220 to 288 therms/yr. They use house air and would be more efficient if
they drew outside air; but I couldn't find a model that was designed for
that at the time.
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.