Hi Dave!
D > Plastic or Fabric? D > Advice/opinions needed. D > D > Central Minnesota in an area with known with damp/wet D > basement problems (4 foot deep split level) D > D > The stone landscaping and plastic has been removed, low D > spots filled (not tamped) in with dirt and graded away from D > the house with the intent to put the stone back around the D > foundation. (about 4ft border) D > D > Neighbor wants to use fabric instead of plastic because he D > has "water bugs" and was told this was because the plastic D > doesn't let the ground dry out, giving the bugs a place to live.
Umm, "water bugs" is another name of cockroachs! When they spray your neighbour's home have them do your property (including shed, outdoor storage areas) when they do his, otherwise the little varmits will set up residency with you.
Anyway, back to the fabric vs. plastic issue. I would recommnd landscaping fabric. Have 'played' with various underlayments for the barked/mulched and rocked areas. Newspaper (several layers thick) will eventually decompose requiring reworking the area. (Used the portion of the paper printed with soy-based ink. Did not use the clay-based inserts.)
Plastic does not allow drainage. Also wood chips will slide off on a slope; probably float if flat. White rock gets dirty looking due to the mud and gunkies trapped above the plastic.
D > Will the use of fabric relieve the bug problem? D > Will the use of fabric (when graded away from the house) be the D > same/more/less effective at reducing the dampness than what could D > be expected using plastic?
The plastic would also trap moisture by not allowing it to evaporate.
- ¯ barry.martinþATþthesafebbs.zeppole.com ®
- A true friend reaches for your hand and touches your heart.