OT: Colorado Fire Evacuees Return To Find Property Burglarized, Vandalized

Are you still stealing movies off the Internet?

Yea, but I download more music than movies. But that's better than "stealing" them from the homes of Colorado fire evacuees - isin't it?

Besides, nobody's ever been charged for *downloading* anything from the net. The crime is making them available for others to download.

That makes you a common thief -- there is no difference in you and those in this case.

Liar and a thief.

This is your lie, so tell it anyway you like.

The theft of property is insurable.

Do the music or movie studios insure themselves against this "theft" that you purport I (and others) do?

Do insurance companies compensate the studio's for the "loss" of these properties?

It's a fact. Go look it up.

The obtainment of copyrighted material over the internet boils down to an infraction of a license agreement. The material is not treated as real property. The violation is performed by the person who makes the material available to others (via download, storing it on physical media and giving it to others, etc).

Don't you think it diminishes the loss that those people in Colorado have suffered when you compare breaking into their homes, destroying and stealing their property - with downloading some movies or music from the internet?

When real property is stolen, it may very well be irreplaceable.

Music and movies, on the other hand, are never really stolen (in the conventional sense) and are trivial to duplicate.

is it your contention that the only thing that makes and action "theft" is if the stolen item is insured?

You imagine pink fairies and flying purple elephants, too, but seldom anything real.

Maybe not. Those kind likely will do more crime and forget about this crime. Nobody would like my justice.... unless self defense upon yourself or for another person, you die immediately !!!! No mercy. This way there is no repeat offenders. Of course this might eliminate maybe 10,000,000 people but it will make the prisons less crowded and we won't have to feed these guys till they die like Charles Manson or the like. I think we would lessen crime a bit and make others think twice before they do the crime... and if I'm wrong, they won't get a 2nd chance.

so I can take your dog without any fear of prosecution?

didn't you get the news: the wasting bandwidth argument died a painful death when people started downloading songs and movies illegally

then explain what you think the purpose of copyright is

based on your definition if someone were to hack into your computer and copy every single bit of your personal data and then place it somewhere for me to peruse, I would not be guilty of any crime

explain how it would be different from stealing a book from a bookstore