The icemaker in my refrigerator quit making ice. I called an appliance repair company, (which turned out to be a one man operation) who said the problem was with a valve that wasn't working. He said he charges $45 for the call plus parts. He replaced the valve and also said a filter behind the refrigerator was leaking and he replaced that. (I never had seen evidence of leakage near the refrigerator). Before he left I noticed that no water was coming into the cube making area and he claimed I had to wait for it to cycle again. He charged $140.00 plus $30.00 to replace the filter. Later that I night I found that the icemaker was still not filling or making ice. I called him and he said he probably needed to replace the whole icemaker.
Is there a validity to what he said? Should I stop payment on the check? Should I let him come out again? Should I eat my losses and get a new company? What is fair to him and fair to me? I am no better off that before I called him and I am out $170.
What should I do at this point?