Follow-up on European phones in the USA

Follow-up on European phones in the USA

The upshot is, an expensive phone might work the same in Europe and the USA, but a year-2019 250 dollar Android phone will not, unless you get a Global model.

In most cases, the product description in an advertisement or webpage doesn't say if it's Global or not. And it probably isnt'. And it doesn't say when you buy it what bands and frequencies it can work with unless you know which submodel you're getting, and maybe not even then.

And even when you're using it, the basic phone won't say what band you are using it on, but now (I don't think they used to) Network Signal Info and Metwork Signal Info Pro will say and will give a lot of Wifi and cell tower location info also.

GSMARENA.com often gives the varying bands/frequencies for different submodels but not all the time. Look at the grey lines under the green bars

formatting link
They say Versions: SM-A305F/DS (Global); SM-A305FN/DS (Europe); SM-A305G/DS (LATAM); SM-A305GT/DS (Brazil); SM-A305GN/DS (APAC); SM-A305YN (AU/NZ) I have A305F. It seems to be Global, but you'll see in some areas I only got 2G when with my newer phone, I get 4G. A big difference.

It lists the bands: 4G bands 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 20, 38, 40, 41 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 12, 13, 17, 20, 28, 38, 40, 41, 66

But it doesn't say which bands are on which phones!! (Some entries in GSMARENA do say that. I've only looked at a few phones but this is the first time I noticed that it didn't.)

1 and 3 are Europe, but 2 and 4 are the most popular bands in the USA. (Not only that, but I think the last timee I looked this phone had 3 of the four of 1,2,3,4. Now it has either 2 or 4 of them.

formatting link
is the meaning of the/DS? Several guesses by posters, "DS menas Dual Sim device " That seems likely. Another guy says it means global, but it couldn't becaue they are all DS including all the others, which are specifcally for Europe, Latin America, Brazil, and "Asia and Pacific". At any rate my old phone does have the F, which seems to mean something.

My first Global phone, the stolen one, was a Xiaomi I bought directly from Hong Kong. I paid about $250 for this but it would have been cheaper in the USA. The second was also Xioami bought from Amazon. I paid $275 for this in the USA>

Neither had the annoying Samsung practice of having to tap the bottom left corner to get to the apps. Just go sideways from the home page.

Background: You may remember this story on one or both of these newsgroups.

My phone was in my rentacar when I parked in an area in Athens known for car breakins. Known to locals but not to tourists like me. The phone (and other stuff) was stolen, and I had to buy a replacement phone.

I had already read from people on Trip Advisor, from professional tour guides, that any phone I bought in Greece would work in the USA. OTOH, anyone willing to pay 1000's extra for a guided tour might spend more than 250 for the phone. And arent' all iphones more than 250***.

So I bought a new one. I paid about $250 for a Samsung Galaxy A30 (SM-A305F, whatever that means). And it did work but a few months after I got back, I started to have doubts.

Later, spring of 2021, I was Morgan Run environmental area about 25 miles west of downtown Baltimore and I could make phone calls but could not use google satellite view, which uses data** Then just west of Harper's Ferry WVa, but there a teenager told me people didn't have any data there either. Then the Patapso River valley at Ilchrester, but there 3 teenagers told me that they didn't have any data either and I should go to the top of the adjoining hill, at least 100 feet high. Then two other locations in Baltimore itself. (I know where they were and had planned to go back) Then Hollywood Maryland. No google maps sat view. This time I thought to use an app to see what band I was using, and while it diidn't give the band it did say I was using GSM 2G !!! I thought there was no

2G left. Didn't I read that? But I didn't have my new, Global phone with me, and it's a 2 hour drive from my house. Then yesterday New Holland, Pa. and again, just 2G. This time I had brought the new phone so I found a good place to sit, without places for the sim to hide like in my car, and I changed the sim to the new phone and voila, 4G, in the very same spot.

I'm going to go back to those three locations in Baltimore and see if I have data now, 4G even, but I'm sure I will.

If you really want, go to

formatting link
and enter

330 East Main Street, New Holland, PA and you'll see the coverage.

Mint Mobile uses T-moblie towers, but does that mean the coverage area is exactly the same as T-mobile?

Strength is shown with little drawings, Outdoors, in the car, in a house, in a steel frame office building.

It's 5G 4G LTE 2100 xxxx 4G LTE 1900 xxxx 4G LTE 700 xxxx 4G LTE 600 xxxx 3G/4G UMTS 2100 x Outside only 2G GSM 1900 xxx Outside or in the car only.

**That's why I asked if phone calls were still different from data, and I think I was told on the android group that they no longer were. Yet I was able to use the phone but nothing else. So how is that?

***(There can be a problem going the opposite direction too. My first 5" smart phone was Blu. They are made largelly for Latin America. I bought in the US, and it worked fine in the US, but in Greece it could only get

2G and not 3G and google translate would not work, except verrrrry slowly, 10 minutes for a video answer. Also in Greece my telephoto lens app worked and didn't show any ads, even though I hadn't paid. Later I realized it was trying to show ads but 2G wasn't adequate to show them! (That part was good.))
Reply to
micky
Loading thread data ...

I have a very cheap Samsung Galaxy A42 that I use every day in Europe. Will it work ok with a USA prepay nano-SIM card when I travel to the USA?

Reply to
Peter

What do you call very cheap? :-) What I find is the Samsung Galaxy A42 5G. Is that the one you mean? With 5G? The cheapest price I find is $320, which is $45 more than what I paid (18 months ago.) I don't think that is very cheap. Blu might be very cheap, at least their cheap models.

If this is the one you have, this one seems unusual in that it doesn't have any submodels listed by number, but it's clear that there are submodels because the page below refers to dual sim model and Europe. You use yours in Europe but did you buy it in Europe, at a store there or a mail order company located there? (Even then it's conceivable they sold a different model. Maybe someone asked them to order it but he never picked it up** Or the wholesaler shipped the wrong phone.)

This is the gsmarena page:

formatting link

In this case the qustion is sort of academic because the webpage lists two sets of bands and the Europe set is the same as the other except it's missing 34 and 39.

It does have 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 12, 17, 20, 28, 38, 40, 41 - Europe

And 2 and 4 are the most popular, iiuc in the USA. I know almost nothing about other bands. I think I was once using band 41 but I don't know why.

So I think you're in very good shape.

Even with the wrong phone, I was able to use it in cities. Except twice, and those places***, if I went a quarter mile away or whatever, I'd be in range of a different tower which might have different bands. And of course whoever is providing the cellular service makes a differnce.

I think all the cellular services have coverage maps on the web. You can click on the mint mobile map and it gives details about the frequnencies/bands that it transmits on in that cell.

**You should look on the box it came in or in the settings to see if a submodel is listed. It might matter some day.
Reply to
micky

It's within the same price range as you stated in the original post.

I didn't mention the 5G because it's the only one they make.

I paid less but it's still in the same price range as in your OP.

I bought it in Europe.

I don't know anything about bands. I just want to know if it works in the USA since you said Android doesn't.

Thank you.

That's all I wanted to know because you said "a year-2019 250 dollar European Android phone will not work in the USA, unless you get a Global model."

Mine is in that same price range.

I'm going to use a prepaid plan from one of the JFK vending machines. I'll look for a prepaid plan that has free roaming if they make them.

If it has free roaming, does it even matter which tower I'm nearby to?

All I care about is whether it will work at Yale where I'm going to live for a month and if I can get a nano-SIM at JFK in one of the vending machines.

Which cellular phone carrier do you know of that has a good 1 month plan? (I probably will be on wifi a lot so 2 to 3 GB of data should last me.)

Reply to
Peter

What I said was "The upshot is, an expensive phone might work the same in Europe and the USA, but a year-2019 250 dollar Android phone will not, unless you get a Global model. "

It won't work the same in Europe and the US. Not that it won't work.

You rearranged my sentence, and then put it in quotes. Rearranging is okay usually, if you keep the meaning the same, but even then, putting it in quotes afterwards is not. Quotes mean you are quoting what was said, word for word, not just what you think was meant. And so unnecessary now that we have copy and paste. I said it will not work the same on both continents.

And mine is not very cheap either. :-)

I don't know about that stuff, but my impression is if you have bands 2 and 4, you're in good shape anywhere in the US. OTOH, if that were true, why do they have those other bands? Deep thoughts.

It probably depends on if enough people at Yale have cell phones. Does anyone know about that? Compared to farmland.

I don't know anything about that.

Reply to
micky

Am 04.10.21 um 22:46 schrieb micky:

Roughly since the US has a resonable digital mobile network - around the year 2001 - phones that are sold outside the US can be used globally.

Already back in 2003 I had a Motorola that could be used on all continents. It was a standard phone, nothing special.

All phones that are sold today in Europe can be used everywhere. Since the advent of LTE and 5G anyway.

Reply to
Joerg Lorenz

...

No, he did not say "Android doesn't".

The important thing is precisely what bands does your phone have, and what bands does your USA provider have. Not if it is Android, version, year, price.

...

yes.

Reply to
Carlos E. R.

Like Micky said, look up the specific phone and variant on Gsmarena.com. Under specs, network, it will show the bands it supports. Then compare it to the bands that the carrier uses. Another thing, Micky is talking about global phones, that should not be confused with international phones. Many phone companies have phones with US variants and international variants, with the international not supporting US. All the carriers also have online checkers to tell you if the phone is compatible or not, but I wouldn't trust those. I've seen many cases where it says a phone is compatible, but it's only barely compatible, has just a couple of the carrier bands.

Adding to the confusion, 3g is being shutdown in about a year or less. So those with older phones need to make sure their phones support Volte, voice over LTE, or they won't work when that happens. Carriers are already refusing to activate those phones and some are already cutting off existing ones, sometimes with no notice.

Reply to
trader_4
[snip]

Eyup. Acquantiances of mine using Tracfones (which contracts out to the actual cellcos) woke up to find their phones had turned into bricks...

Reply to
danny burstein

I saw online where it happened to someone on AT&T too. They claim no warnings, no notice, the phone just stopped working one day. And it didn't stop because the carrier services are no longer there, it stopped because AT&T just kicked the phone off. They called AT&T and were told they need a new phone. I agree, and a new carrier too.

Reply to
trader_4

They probably got a notice and tossed it thinking it was junk mail. It could also be like I do. When I get bills I just look to see who from and how much. Then go to the computer and get the bank up and click the place I want to pay, how much , and when. Toss all the other stuff in the envelope.

I forgot what cell service I had about 10 or 15 years ago but got a notice the phone would no longer work on their system after a certain date. It may have been AT&T. They gave me the choice of several phones I could get from them to use afer that update. I am thinking that if I stayed with the simple flip phones like I had they sent me some new ones for free, or could op to buy new smart phones.

I don't hardly ever use my phone and that service you put me on to a few years back as served my needs well.

Reply to
Ralph Mowery

It's more likely they missed and/or ignored the warnings.

The 2G shutdown Jan 1, 2017 affected a number of people with older phones and a bunch of IOT devices (e.g. solar inverter telemetry, etc). AT&T announced it in 2012, which is five years warning.

Reply to
Scott Lurndal

Why is this being cross-posted to uk.telecom.mobile?

Reply to
Java Jive

Aha!! I thought there was a 2G shutdown, 4 years ago you say, but if you red my OP carefully, you'd see that I was getting 2G GSM at locations in southern maryland and near Lancaster, Pa. (New Holland). Just 9 and 2 days ago.

So how is that possible?

In Pa. I could even get satellite view, just slowly. I could put my sim back into the previous phone and go there now and do it some more.

Reply to
micky

AT&T shut down their 2g in 2017. Verizon Jan 1 2021, Sprint Jan 1 2022.

see above.

Reply to
Scott Lurndal

Good to hear that Mint is still working well for you. Same here, I've been with them 4 years now. There are increasing reports in the forums that some people are being hit hard with deprioritization. Mint like all MVMOs is at the bottom of the priority list. So if capacity is limited and a lot of phones are in use, eg at a big sports game, a fair, then your data service could go to unusable. I haven't had it happen to me, but a friend who's been on Mint for a couple years, used it here in NJ, NYC, Boston, LA with no problems went to Las Vegas, he had essentially no service for days while on the strip there. Soon as he got out of that area, it went back to normal. It's what you get when you're paying $180 for a year. :) Just thought I'd give you a heads up on that in case you run into it.

Reply to
trader_4

Thanks for the heads up. I am in a small town and the larger towns are about 40 miles away on each side of me. Most likely my service will be slow if it snows. Back when everyone was on the old POTS and it snowed everyone called to tell their friends it was snowing. That made it difficult go get a call through. I probably have only used the data service an average of 4 times a month. Mostly when I take my wife to the hair dresser and wait for her. If I could save up things from month to month I would probably have enough data and minuites for the rest of my life it I only got 200 minuites a month.

Reply to
Ralph Mowery

My uncle just got a notice that their phone will no longer be supported sometime in October - but their phone service supplier was unaware that they had already upgraded to a significantly niwer and more capable"old phone" than the old Samsung flip phone they had sold him 20 years ago. (now a 3g capable Blackberry Torch that's only about

10 years old)
Reply to
Clare Snyder

I thought it was interesting that long after they said AMPS66 (1g?) was dropped by the majors, I could still make a call on my old bag phone. It was $3.99 a minute ala carte but as little as I used a phone, that was still cheaper than any plan that was offered at the time. I ended up with a Jitterbug for $100 a year that I couldn't use all the minutes on.

Reply to
gfretwell
[snip]

Verizon has put this off more than once. Originally, Verizon was going to shut down at the end of 2019. Now it's the end of 2022 (T-mobile as well). I got these numbers from

formatting link

Reply to
Mark Lloyd

HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.