So I had my heart set on the classic agitator top loader, the old school tank style one everyone raves about. I was one click away from ordering the pair for well over what I planned to spend. Then I spent three hours last night reading through old posts here instead of sleeping. What acutally changed my mind was the comforter thing. Multiple people pointed out that a big king comforter basicly wraps around a center post agitator and never gets fully wet, so you end up rewashing it anyway. I always assumed the agitator scrubbing action was what got stuff clean, but it sounds like the wash motion and enought water per load matter way more, and an impeller machine with a bulky bedding cycle handles a comforter better. Ended up canceling my cart and ordering a plain mid range front load pair instead. It was actually cheaper than what I was about to blow, and my comforter should flop around freely in the drum like it's supposed to. Still a little sad I'm not getting that tank-like beast, but my credit card is relieved. Delivery is Friday, I'll report back after the first comforter wash.
Changed my washer order last night and I think I dodged a bullet
Nov 05, 2026
Last reply: 4 days ago
3 Replies
Follow replies to this discussion?
Information here may be outdated?
I went through a similar process when I was replacing my old Whirlpool with a new set for the laundry room. I was really leaning towards a big top loader because my schedule just didn't allow for running loads late at night. But like the user here, reading other people's issues made me pause. My concern wasn't really the comforter, but rather heavy towels and those big fleece blankets I rotate for the winter. I realized that even a high-end agitator might just not give the deep massage needed for items that are that dense. I eventually settled on a front load because the way those blankets drape and move around inside the drum is just fundamentally diferent than they do trapped around a central post. For example, when you wash a king-sized duvet, if the washing action is too gentle, it just ends up looking like it was rolled in a gentle hug. With the tumbling action, it actually gets exposed to more of the wash water and detergent. I used a Samsung model, and I found the heavy duty cycle was perfect for the thick winter linens. It felt like the fabric was really being worked through, not just rinsed over. It was a bit of a price jump from the top loaders, but my laundry has never felt less stiff after a wash.
My experience was pretty similar when I upgraded mine, but my focus was less on how the clothes got clean and more on the long-term mechanics. I had a Whirlpool agitator for years, and around the four year mark, I started noticing some play in the base of the mechanism. It wasn't a catastrophic failure, just a noticeable wobble that made me wonder how many cycles it had left before it needed a full overhaul. Switching to a front load fixed that mechanical worry entirely.
I also found the entire laundry room much quieter. The biggest difference in the daily routine wasn't the washing performance itself, but the lack of that loud splashing and churning noise that always seemed to travel through the walls. For my household, which means running a load during the day when the house is full, the reduced volume was a deciding factor. It felt like a significant quality of life improvement over the old top-spinner. While the saturation argument is a very valid one for bedding, I also found the consistent tumbling action of the drum handled those oversized, bulky towels better for me. They just seemed to seperate and fluff up properly without getting stuck against that central agitator pole.
One thing I learned after switching to a front loader is to check the level on delivery day before the guys leave. Mine sat on a slightly sloped floor and walked itself halfway across the laundry room within a month. A few turns on the lock nuts and it's been quiet since. Also get in the habit of leaving the door cracked between loads, that rubber gasket will get musty fast if it stays sealed up wet.
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required