Disassemble Smear with silicone goo. Do up finger tight or even less. Wipe of excess carefully. Wait a day Do up tight.
The silicone will forme a perfectly matched rubbery gasket, which will be think enough to tighten down properly after curing. I learnt this trick from a plumber - he threw all the washers way, and simply used silicone on everything. None of his joints, or the ones I made using his technique, have leaked.
I take it you're putting the sealant above the sink but below the fitting? In other words, sandwiched by the top of the sink and underside of the fitting? In which case, use hemp with the Bosswhite laid out in the form of a ring, or use silicone sealant if there's no washer provided. Or get a washer.
I used something called "plumbers putty". It was on the shelf next to Boss White and Hemp. It is like a sticky version of plasticine. I rolled a "sausage" of the stuff (after several attempts), cleaned all surfaces as far as possible, checked the existing seals were not fractured or deteriorating, placed the sausage over the "parts" that were to meet, screwed it all back together (hope this makes sense), cleaned off excess with a modelling knife. Neat job, no leaks. Took 30 mins in total being careful.
Whatever material you use I think it needs to flexible so frame sealant is out.
HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.