Anthracite coal ash on the garden - bad or OK?

Normally coal ash isn't recommended for composting - I presume to heavy metals that may be present (eg Hg).

Anyone know the specifics of anthracite in contrast? Suitable or not for the compost bin?

Ta

Tim

Reply to
Tim W
Loading thread data ...

bit of a google and nah I wouldn't risk it on me veg's either...

cheers JimK

Reply to
JimK

JimK wibbled on Friday 11 December 2009 17:07

Sorry - did an insufficient google. Tried again with different terms. Seems that it has the risk of arsenic etc but is also low in potassium unlike wood ash, so there's no net benefit and an element of risk.

Reply to
Tim W

s'ok I wasn;t being sniffy :>) a good question... I have to remember not to chuck ash from burning painted wood (ahem, whistle....) into the compost or on the flower beds.... also some of our garden seems to be "made" of old "red" fire ashes - let's say "not a lot grows there......" - you didn't happen to see anything specifically about red fire ash did you?

cheers JimK

Reply to
JimK

JimK wibbled on Friday 11 December 2009 19:33

Some people out there reckon it's good in the ice as something to sprinkle on the ice.

Reply to
Tim W

wish "the ancients" had done that here!

Cheers JimK

Reply to
JimK

It may be a bit radioactive as well.

Reply to
Roger Dewhurst

HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.