I'm in the process of replacing one set of DIY'd desks (wall-to-wall computer desks) with a new, "better" pair.
I've previously seen (and was tempted by) pre-made oak desk-tops, formed by glueing several PSE boards together with a double row of biscuits. This seemed like a good idea, so I trotted down to the local timber merchants to price up oak, and other hardwoods, in order to do the same (cost of delivery of the pre-mades being the major factor, here, plus, I've fancied dabbling with a bit of woodwork for a while).
Now, whilst chatting to the guy at the timberyard, who suggested he used to do "a lot of this" in a previous life, he suggested that he would never use biscuits because... (at this point, his quiet nature, the sound of the timber yard, my age-induced deafness and nack of interrupting at inopportune times) meant I missed the whole explanation, but it centred around some argument of the strength of the glued joint being so much more than the strength of the wood...
Can anyone explain in a more clear way (to me) the rationale behind this?
As an alternative approach, he suggested (I think the phrase was...) a false tongue using a hard-wood fillet (using a circular/table saw to cut a groove along each edge of the boards, and inserting (and presumably glueing) a hard-wood insert to form the tongue.... ASCII art alert:-
########## ========= ####### +++++ ====== ########## =========
# : 1st board = : 2nd board
- : fillet
Which would require me to knock up a jig for doing this (or borrowing my dad's table-saw.... there's an idea)
...or... to use a rebate joint, glued...
############## ========= ############## ========= ####### ================= ####### =================
Which I could do easily enough with a router, I'm sure.
Now, the false tongue - I can understand, although is it not simply a "very long biscuit"?, so why's this preferable to a double-row of biscuits?
The rebate joint just... I dunno... doesn't feel right - it relies completely on the strength of the glue bond to provide the strong work-surface needed for a desk-top.
Any comments? (would be gratefully received - it's a lot of expensive wood that I'm about to start molesting, and this is my first experiment beyond pine/soft-wood)
Mike