An "American Oak" tree problem

[snip]

Don't go back, go forward. I think in this case you'd be better off checking with a local arborist rather than Usenet replies -- arborist thinking in the U.S. opposed the use of concrete and fillers starting many years ago, because it interferes with the tree's own efforts to repair itself and is likely to lead to rotting wood and other problems. Local nurseries still sell stuff for filling in tree wounds, but that's a victory of marketing and out-of-date information over effectiveness.

Before you spend any money to "save" the tree, check with local arborists to see if this is a known problem species while it's still young and easy to replace. Your nursery may have an insecticide for the borer (that's what it sounds like you have) but you might also check with a local arborist and see if borers are a known problem with this type of tree. While it's young you might just want to replace it with a different variety, especially something that's a native tree, rather than keep trying to save a tree that's in the wrong region and in steady decline --

If you're at one of the American bases in Germany you may be able to find someone in Civil Engineering with local knowledge of trees and a list of problem species.

Reply to
JimR
Loading thread data ...

Hugh Johnson's "The International Book of Trees" (which I previously mis-cited as the "World Book of Trees") gives "White Oak" as the common name for Q. alba, without "American". It's range is from south-east Canada to eastern U.S. Johnson also says that it is not successful in Europe.

Reply to
David E. Ross

I showed that to my wife (particularly the last line), and she said she thought she remembered that it was said that it was an "American Red Oak". :) Who knows - it was surely just marketing giberish anyway ... it turns nicely red in the fall - but I guess all oaks do...

Lesson learned - make sure you keep your gardening receipts....

Reply to
Charles T. Smith

HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.