I have been using plan B for long time. Then yesterday a friend told me that his WW'ing company does plan A all the time. I would prefer plan A (makes the raised panels even on both sides), but plan B would be stronger? This is about using biscuits and glue.
Chuck
Maybe I'm missing something... but it's not at all clear to me what the illustrations represent, or what you're asking. Please explain further.
Maybe it's me, but I fail to see the relationship between those mitred corners and raised panels.
Absolutely Plan A. With "A" you end up with the false corners that hide the actual joint. These can easily be put together with pocket hole screws if the inside will not show.
It's 3/4" thick lumber, with one cut at 45-degree on both sides. Then glued all together. This makes a "safer" corner rather a sharp pointing edge.
I am asking which would be stronger (obvious Plan A), but was told that one company does Plan B, so just wondering.
Chuck
The "un-mitred" lumber would be the raised panels. Otherwise, forget it.
Chuck
I meant I used Plan A all along. Not Plan B...
Obvious Plan A would be "stronger", but was told that one company does Plan B, so just wondering.
As for using raised panels, I glue the RP onto the mitred cut, then sand it. This will leave one side "2-1/2" and other "2-3/4" looks. I know I could adjust the stiles to compensate... should I? Maybe not.
Hmm, in case you looking at this in a different way, I am looking at the
45-degree corners for the outside, while the inside would be hidden.I still like using biscuits. I use pocket hole occasionally.
Chuck
With that kind of corner and joint the biscuits are OK but the pocket holes pull the joint up tighter and more easily. It is often hard to clamp that type corner joint .
Plan C (22.5-degree cuts on each)
Add my vote to that to.
Bill
Why? I think it's OK idea, was there a reason for that? Pocket holes?
Chuck
Hi Chuck,
I never thought of anything like plan "A" until I bought a Kreg PS jig about 2 weeks ago. It made a lot of sense to me for my current project where the back side is not visible (as shown in their owners booklet).
One thing is certain. It requires cutting only one angle at something other than 90, so if you're trying to fit some trim, you are only working with one edge.
Don't think that it's perfect for every situation, but it's a good solution in some.
Lou
Definitely, neither A nor B seem even remotely correct.
HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.