Hmmm. Weehawken is not really the center of the woodworking universe,
but there's a few places you might want to visit if you are willing to
drive a bit, most not exclusively woodworking store type places, but
more tool supply houses - thats all there really is in New Jersey.
Force and AW Meyer are more in the power tool suppy business and don't
really have a deep inventory of high quality hand tools, although I
have purchased many things from both and they certainly have
handscrews. Both have full showrooms of all sorts of powertools and
you could spend an hour or two just poking around and playing with
tablesaws, lathes and shapers. Garrett Wade has a catalog operation,
but also has a small showroom which I spend an hour or so in every
summer when I am in the city, its at 161 Avenue of the Americas in
Manhattan, not all that far from Weehawkin by ferry and some public
transportation. They don't really advertise their showroom, and its
located in a non-descript building - ask the doorman how to find it
inside the building as there are no signs, but if you're in the area
its worth the trip. As you can see from their website, its more of
what you have in mind and they do carry some higher end handtools.
Finally, Woodcraft, which is a franchise of retail stores as well as a
catalog operation, recently opened a store in Allentown, Pennsylvania,
which is about a 2 hour drive from Weehawkin, straight west on
Interstate 78, directions can be had by navigating the website. It,
too, is more what you have in mind as you can see from their website.
Its a bit of a drive, but on a nice day you can see some of the
countryside on the way. See the links below. Bring your money, as the
exchange rate is in your favor nowadays. Good luck.