First off I'm pretty new to woodworking but getting into it quickly. My
question is two-parted so I'll just split it up.
Periodically I see posts/hear about people getting large slabs of burl maple
or cherry or something for very low costs. Just where are they getting
things like this. Are there wood swap meets (I live in Tulsa, OK) or flea
markets for wood? I'm really interested in getting something around
4"x6"x6" or similiar. Local cabinetmakers only tend to have scrap in the
3/4" or less range. Woodcrafters wants about $30 for a chunk that size.
Also - I'm getting ready to do a project making a small jewelry box out of
solid maple (burled, quilted, spalted or something interesting) by routing
out the compartments inside. Saw the project in Art of the Router. I've
practiced on MDF (laminated), just to get the idea and process down and it
came out well, but am worried I'll burn the maple plunging out all the
innards of the compartments. I used a cheap (carbide but cheap) bit to do
the sides and bull nose the bottom inside edge of it with no problem but are
these going to burn the maple up? They definitely dont cut as easily as the
CMT bit I have (fancy little classical ogee). Should I just buck up and buy
a CMT (they have a 1 1/4" long bull nose that would work great)? My router
is a PC 690 (or 691 or 3 or something, plunge and fixed base), would a
variable speed controller help me out here or is just letting it go full
sorry for all the questions, but I really appreciate the help
Sorry about on-topic questions? Why?
That's what this place is here for, though lately you might thing this was
I can't answer you. Burl? Sounds expensive. Wood swap meets? Never heard
of such a thing. We only have one hardwood supplier hereabouts, and they
don't stock much and charge too much for it. Router bits? I hate routers.
I only have one of the screamin' banshees, and I practically never use it.
Good questions though. Someone should be along eventually, I hope.
Michael McIntyre ---- Silvan < firstname.lastname@example.org>
Linux fanatic, and certified Geek; registered Linux user #243621
I own 17 routers and the school has over 50. I love routers and love
the work that they can do. A router is just a way to accomplish your
task. In woodworking as in life there is no secrets....you normally
get what you pay for and there is no free lunch. Try and buy the best
you can afford. Using good quality tools is a blessing. Every now
and then you might get lucky and get a good deal on wood, but not
everyday. Try and establish yourself at your local wood dealer and
get to know them. Practise good lumber yard ettique when shopping.
This way your wood dealer will take good care of you too.
Usually the cost of wood is very low in comparision to your time. I
have seen work that was done with shody material and took the worker
40 hours to make, if they had spent just a little more money on
material, the project would have been nice. Good luck and happy
Mike from American Sycamore Woodworkers' Retreat
This is so true.
I'm working on making some boxes for gifts. American Woodworker has plans
for a simple box and lid that with a couple of fixtures can be turned out
easily. To set up the fixtures and get ready for a run of 6 or 8 of then I
figured I use some pine boards from the Borg. Resawed a board, planed and
set aside for an hour. Came back and found a nice "S" curve in the wood.
Not even good enough for test pieces. Meantime, I took a piece of elm
leftover from another project and in the same time have perfect pieces.
You're contemplating a first class project here. Do not scrimp on the
tools needed nor the wood you buy. Every now and then somebody here
will post that a neighbor cut down some maple/walnut/oak... trees and
gave them to the poster free. This is usually met with a chorus of
"nice haul" or more commonly "you suck". A neighbor once gave me his
redwood deck which was great, but I don't have others beating on my door
to make me happy. Do some price comparing ($30 doesn't seem all that
bad) and cost/benefit estimating and do the best you can. Try some yard
sales, especially if tools are mentioned. Crane your neck to see if
there is anything stacked in the back yard, in the garage, by the trash,
etc. and try to cut a deal.
As far as cutters are concerned, go with quality. You don't want a
piece ruined because the bit/blade/cutter... you saved $20 on, came apart.
In other words, spend the money and get on with the fun stuff. To
paraphrase somebody's sig here, buy the best and cry once.
Well, I was stationed in Enid, and trees were rare Tulsa a bit better. Get
over toward Arkansas and cruise for small mills. Hillier the land, less
likely it's making money farming, so that's where I'd search. Take a good
pickup or trailer, and stock up.
My kid dragged a trailer north to visit, filled it with wood to tow back to
Texas and paid for his entire vacation, so you might consider a vacation in
the area where your desired species are common.
I've used bits to make boxes. Key is to have a big enough template base to
move the router all the way to the edge without tipping, and use that
bottoming bit to clean up the last 8th or 16th. Rest of the work can be
done with collar and a spiral upcut, wasting away an eighth at a time.
Jeff, for the wood take a look at eBay. I'm not sure there are any
tremendous bargains on eBay but it is a great place to pick up that
odd piece of wood that would be extremely time consuming to find by
Go to www.ebay.com, search under crafts > woodworking > lumber or
crafts > woodworking > turning and you'll be amazed at what's
I don't know what to tell you. In my limited experience, I've always
been marginally happier when I bought the better tool. Most conspicuous
example was the Forrest blade for the contractor's saw. I couldn't
believe the improvement. There are a million bargains to be had and
they are really great. Day in and day out, you get what you pay for.
I think you'll be able to get what you want out of the PC at full speed,
making a jewelry box, if you watch your feed rate. I can't imagine
you'll be using any really large diameter bits to hollow out your burl.
Variable speed is worth the chips if you're using bits over about 3/4"
dia. That and below, you can usually get pretty good results at the
full rated RPM of most routers.
Jeff Anderson wrote:
Find a saw mill or lumber yard and haunt the scrap/burn pile. One saw mill
here cuts only straight boards and will throw away any odd shaped/grained
lumber. It is surprising what you can find dumpster diving at lumber yards.
Go here and search for "sawmills" Often mills that make pallets, etc.
consider burls and wild grain to be defects and they go on the pile of
slabs they sell at a discount for firewood.
HomeOwnersHub.com is a website for homeowners and building and maintenance pros. It is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.