Wiki: Sharpen cutlery

Another one to play with....

NT

Sharpen cutlery

Sharp kitchen knives make hard jobs easy, reduce fatigue, and reduce the risk of accident due to putting too much force on a knife and losing control.

==Considerations== ===Metals=== The quality of steel used in knives varies fairly widely. Some knives can take a very sharp edge, most can be made fairly sharp, and the occasional bad one is barely capable of becoming sharp at all.

===Angles=== Specific angles are best for specific metals and jobs, but with kitchen knives one is usually working with unknown budget metal, and not looking for a razor edge. The thinner the angle, the more sharp the blade is initially, but the quicker it blunts. And with popular low cost cutlery, blunting at narrow angles can be very quick. Also the poorest quality metal, found on some table knives, is sometimes unable to take 35 degrees without the cutting edge pitting during grinding.

The following angles work well for me:

Cutting knives: 30 degrees.

  • sharp
  • blunts quickly if used with glass boards or ceramic plates

Table knives: 40 degrees

  • mildly sharp
  • child friendly
  • works on any steel
  • retains its mildly sharp edge well
  • Not very sharp, but a big improvement on a blunt knife.

Its possible to place a printed angle under the grinder to act as a guide if wanted. Personally I don't lose sleep over precision here, kitchen knives are far from critical high performance tools. If you buy high cost knives, you should follow the original grinding angles to ensure you get the best possible performance. Most people however are working with unknown material, and its not possible to specify what angle will give the best performance for each knife.

If you're determined to tweak your grinding angles to get peak performance out of each knife, it may be worth nothing that in my experience the worst quality metal is found not on cheapo knives, but on pretty table knives from a popular major manufacturer, one most buyers would regard as quality.

==Serrated blades== Serration is a way to get much of the effect of sharpness without real sharpness being present. Serration is widely disliked among knife sharpeners, but its an easy way to get cutting ability from cheap metal, its liked by many end users, and it has its uses, such as cutting frozen food. Consequently it may be wished to sharpen serrated knives without loss of serration.

There's no easy way to maintain the serrated shape indefinitely while sharpening using home equipment. There are however a few successful ways to sharpen serrated knives.

===Sharpen the back=== Often knives are serrated asymmetrically, with serrations ground on one side only. In this case the flat other side of the blade can be ground. Only a small amount of grinding is needed. A final single very light pass on the serrated side removes any burr.

===Sharpen the tips=== Where the above method doesn't produce enough sharpening, the knife may be ground on the serrated side(s) too. The idea here is not to thoroughly grind all areas of the blade, but rather to make the usual fairly quick pass over the blade. This will sharpen the tips only, giving a big improvement in performance. Its good enough for most uses.

===Rough edge=== This technique produces a rough edge with mini serrations, and works well with an angle grinder. I don't know if its possible to do this approach with other grinding tools. The blade is sharpened as normal, but its moved over the grinder disc as quickly as can be done safely, rather than gradually. The idea is to pass the whole length of the blade over the disc in about half a second. The result is fairly sharp, but rough and uneven. It effectively creates ungraceful serrations. A rough old grinding disc creates more serration than a new smooth one.

This method isn't often the best choice, but can be used where existing serrations are too uneven to sharpen usefully, and where conversion to a plain edge is unworkable for some reason, eg not enough metal left, or would require grinding an excessive amount of metal away. Its also a very quick way to deal with serrated knifes that are barely worth the trouble of sharpening.

===Sharpen all=== In principle its possible to sharpen cresent shaped serrations and maintain their shape. However its very time consuming and not very pointful, so not normally done.

===Plain blade conversion=== The final option is to remove enough metal to convert the knife to a plain blade. This is usually not necessary, but is the only way to ensure a blade that's sharp every millimetre of its length.

==One sided blades== Many knives come ground on one side only. This causes them to wander off line when cutting, which is a pain in the kitchen. Its a good idea to grind them on the unground side to reduce this tendency, only making a final burr removing pass on the originally ground side.

==Sharpening tools== There are a few ways to sharpen kitchen blades.

===Kitchen knife sharpener=== Many low cost motorised domestic knife sharpeners are available. One go with one of these caused me to abandon all hope.

===Bench grinder=== Bench grinders are the best option in most respects. They are the standard engineer's choice for sharpening a wide range of blades. They don't look particularly graceful in the kitchen though. They also lack the speed of an angle grinder.

===Block=== Manual sharpening is slow, and stock removal even slower. Nevertheless some people prefer this approach.

===Steel=== A traditional steel doesn't grind. Rather it restores a microscopically bent cutting edge by restraightening it. These were used between sharpenings as an intermediate way to prolong sharpness.

Modern performance knives don't use steel that suffers this fate, so a steel isn't much use with them. However cheaper knives do use softer metal, and may benefit from use of a steel.

===Abrasive Steel=== The abrasive steel is a traditional steel but with some added abrasive. It primarily acts like a traditional steel, but also provides a little grinding as well, thus prolonging sharpening intervals further. However hand powered grinding of any sort is a labour intensive way to sharpen knives compared to machine grinding.

===Sandpaper=== Sandpaper may be used on a dead flat surface (eg glass) for sharpening. This has popularly become known as the 'scary sharp' method, as by progressing through increasingly fine grades its possible to achieve a very high level of sharpness.

===Angle grinder=== The suggestion of using an [[angle grinder]] to sharpen knives often raises eyebrows. However they are very fast and effective, able to sharpen a totally blunt knife in 20-30 seconds, and remove stock to create a new edge in under a minute. This speed makes it easy and practical to sharpen all one's knives quickly, table knives included. For busy people this is a real advantage.

====Flaws==== As sharpeners, angle grinders have some sizeable flaws, and some precautions are very necessary.

The knife blade must be kept moving, don't ever grind one stationary spot. Doing so would overheat the metal in 5-10 seconds, and if this happens the blade will never be able to keep an edge again.

The very high disc speed can throw a knife if held to the disc in the wrong direction. Always confirm the direction of rotation before use (eg with a match etc), and take care to hold the knife the right way.

Always use indirect vent goggles, ear defenders, and ideally a full face mask too.

Never use a damp grit disc in an angle grinder, and don't dip cutlery in water to cool it when using such a disc. Damp grit discs can fail violently.

Keep your face out of the plane of rotation of the disc. Grit discs can break violently.

Angle grinder grit discs are somewhat coarse. This coarseness limits the level of sharpness available, but the result is plenty sharp enough for any normal kitchen use. It would not satisfy most die hard knife sharpeners though. Use only the very lightest pressure to achieve the sharpest edge.

Don't use these tools if tired, drunk, drugged, or not really with it. They aren't a nice friendly power tool.

====Use==== If you have an angle grinder stand, use it. If not, the tool may be held on its back to minimise fatigue. Sitting down with it on your knees (in your hand of course) makes it easy to pass knives both ways. However you position it, keep a good firm grip at all times.

To sharpen, move the blade as shown past the disc. Use the lightest of pressure only. 2 strokes on each side of the blade is enough for any blade that already has an edge formed, ie doesn't need stock removal. Finally make a burr removing pass along the other side of the blade (compared to the previous stroke). Use all the pressure of a feather, so the blade only just barely touches the disc.

Stock removal requires just a little pressure, and more passes. Never get the metal hot though, if in any doubt just put the knife down and come back to it a bit later. Dipping the knife in water is not recommended with grit discs, damp can cause violent disc failure.

===Die grinder===

==After grinding== Knives should always be washed after grinding. Grind stones can harbour all sorts of detritus, oil residues, decayed food & so on.

Its also worth warning the rest of the household if previously blunt knives are now psychopathically sharp.

==Care of sharp knives== Use of 30 degree knives on glass chopping boards or ceramic plates blunts them quickly. Most knife sharpeners prefer wooden chopping boards.

Knives with relatively soft steel benefit from use of a steel between sharpenings.

==Still to do== Stainful steel: pre-ss knives are occasionally seen, but I know nothing about their sharpening characteristics.

==See Also==

  • [[Knives]]
  • [[Special:Allpages|Wiki Contents]]
  • [[Special:Categories|Wiki Subject Categories]]

[[Category: [[Category:

Reply to
meow2222
Loading thread data ...

Need to add to sharpening methods

formatting link
have sharpened some serrated knives with a chainsaw file... slow but effective

Sandpaper is for budgies cages or so my old woodwork teacher used to say. He preferred the term glass paper

whichever not for metal

Emery paper or emery cloth for metal

also add ceramic knives

Reply to
TMC

I sharpen most things with a B&D powerfile and it's very effective. If you've not come across this tool before it's like a belt sander but the belts are only 12mm (IIRC) wide. It allows me more control than my angle grinder and is a *lot* safer as the belt is significantly slower and the energy much less. It can be used one-handed quite safely so I usually just hold the knife against a stop with the blade protruding over the edge of the workbench and run the powerfile over it judging the angle by eye. Simple, safe and effective.

Reply to
Calvin Sambrook

What about more "traditional" methods such as oilstones / whetstones etc?

Matt

Reply to
matthew.larkin

These are the experiences of a long-term cook whose two sons are cooks, one currently as a job and the other having done so part-time.

You need to add diamond sharpeners, and the devices that have tiny wetted stones in them, sold for the trade.

Many people use steel-shaped sharpeners that have diamonds in them. I prefer a flat plate with embedded diamonds such as are sold for sharpening tools. One of my sons swears by the wet stone device. I have used a very fine Global flat stone that had to be wetted. It was excellent but *very* expensive and it wore away quickly.

I think you should differentiate bewteen sharpening and grinding or regrinding. Sharpening is putting a fine edge back on a knife using a steel, stone or diamond. When a knife has been sharpened many times the edge is worn back to the thicker material and a fine edge can't be made. At this point you either throw the knife away or have the whole of one flat surface ground away to thin it.

Another point. You usually hone the front face with a few strokes, then the rear face with a few and then back the front again. Not quite sure why but this is general 'good advice' given in the trade. Ratio of two to one, front to back.

What knives do I use? Mostly Globals because of the shape, weight and steel quality. A large cook's knife and a small paring knife get most use. For general paring I love the cheapo plastic handled knives. Oh, and a Chinese cleaver for some work. I went to a master class given by a leading Shanghai chef. He used only a cleaver but did amazing things with it. He cut a chunk of carp and then scored it deeply down from the cut face several times. He then turned it ninety degrees and scored deeply again. He put the piece scored side up in hot oil and it opened up like a chrysanthemum. Chrysanthemum Carp.

Good start though and an excellent idea. I don't know how most people can use the rubbish knives they have, and don't sharpen properly.

Peter Scott

Reply to
Peter Scott

I think it's so that there isn't a minute burr turned over to one side - ISTR looking at a knife after sharpening 1 side and, under a low-powered microscope, there was a bit to 1 side.

Reply to
PeterC

I've added most of the info so far. Few questions though...

sharpening _is_ a process of grinding though (except when a traditional steel is used).

Do you mean 2:1 front to back, or 2 then 2? If the former, how do you define front and back then? (most kitchen knives are symmetrical).

Even a below par sharpen is far better than a totally blunt knife, as is so often found in the home kitchen.

NT

Reply to
meow2222

version 2...

Sharpen cutlery

Sharp kitchen knives make hard jobs easy, reduce fatigue, and reduce the risk of accident due to putting too much force on a knife and losing control.

=Considerations= ==Metals== The quality of steel used in knives varies fairly widely. Some knives can take a very sharp edge, most can be made fairly sharp, and the occasional bad one is barely capable of becoming sharp at all.

==Angles== Specific angles are best for specific metals and jobs, but with kitchen knives one is usually working with unknown budget metal, and not looking for a razor edge. The thinner the angle, the more sharp the blade is initially, but the quicker it blunts. And with popular low cost cutlery, blunting at narrow angles can be very quick. Also the poorest quality metal, found on some table knives, is sometimes unable to take 35 degrees without the cutting edge pitting during grinding.

The following angles work well for me:

Cutting knives: 30 degrees.

  • sharp
  • blunts quickly if used with glass boards or ceramic plates

Table knives: 40 degrees

  • mildly sharp
  • child friendly
  • works on any steel
  • retains its mildly sharp edge well
  • Not very sharp, but a big improvement on a blunt knife.

Special sharp: 20-25 degree

  • extra sharp
  • a knife ground like this is occasionally useful in the kitchen
  • needs to be handled with care
  • not child safe
  • always cut onto a soft surface, or the edge is lost quickly

Its possible to place a printed angle under the grinder to act as a guide if wanted. Personally I don't lose sleep over precision here, the average kitchen knife is far from a critical high performance tool. If you buy high quality knives though, you should follow the original grinding angles to ensure you get the best possible performance. Most people however are working with unknown material, and its not possible to specify what angle will give the best performance for each knife.

If you're determined to tweak your grinding angles to get peak performance out of each knife, it may be worth noting that in my experience the worst quality metal is found not on cheapo knives, but on pretty table knives from a popular major manufacturer that most buyers regard as quality.

If you're having difficulty maintaining the right angles, one can buy angle guides that will hold the blade correctly aligned.

=Serrated blades= Serration is a way to get much of the effect of sharpness without real sharpness being present. Serration is widely disliked among knife sharpeners, but its an easy way to get cutting ability from cheap metal, its liked by many end users, and it has its uses, such as cutting frozen food. Consequently it may be wished to sharpen serrated knives without loss of serration.

There's no easy way to maintain the serrated shape indefinitely while sharpening using home equipment. There are however a few successful ways to sharpen serrated knives.

==Sharpen the back== Often knives are serrated asymmetrically, with serrations ground on one side only. In this case the flat other side of the blade can be ground. Only a small amount of grinding is needed. A final single very light pass on the serrated side removes any burr.

==Sharpen the tips== Where the above method doesn't produce enough sharpening, the knife may be ground on the serrated side(s) too. The idea here is not to thoroughly grind all areas of the blade, but rather to make the usual fairly quick pass over the blade. This will sharpen the tips only, giving a big improvement in performance. Its good enough for most uses.

==Rough edge== This technique produces a rough edge with mini serrations, and works well with an angle grinder. I don't know if its possible to do this approach with other grinding tools. The blade is sharpened as normal, but its moved over the grinder disc as quickly as can be done safely, rather than gradually. The idea is to pass the whole length of the blade over the disc in about half a second. The result is fairly sharp, but rough and uneven. It effectively creates ungraceful serrations. A rough old grinding disc creates more serration than a new smooth one.

This method isn't often the best choice, but can be used where existing serrations are too uneven to sharpen usefully, and where conversion to a plain edge is unworkable for some reason, eg not enough metal left, or would require grinding an excessive amount of metal away. Its also a very quick way to deal with serrated knifes that are barely worth the trouble of sharpening.

==Sharpen all== In principle its possible to sharpen cresent shaped serrations and maintain their shape. However its very time consuming and not very pointful, so not normally done.

==Plain blade conversion== The final option is to remove enough metal to convert the knife to a plain blade. This is usually not necessary, but is the only way to ensure a blade that's sharp every millimetre of its length.

=One sided blades= Many knives come ground on one side only. This causes them to wander off line when cutting, which is a pain in the kitchen. Its a good idea to grind them on the unground side to reduce this tendency, only making a final burr removing pass on the originally ground side.

=Ceramic knives= ?

=Pre-stainess knives= Knives that were made before stainless steel became popular are occasionally seen. Non-rusting cutlery contains a mix of steel, copper, and probably other things, and the metal is usually blotchy and darkened from food stains. These are seen in collections of pre- war cutlery.

I know nothing about their sharpening characteristics though. Until someone that does know can tell us, I would expect the mixed metal content would make them soft, and best suited to 40 degree sharpening.

=Sharpening tools= There are a few ways to sharpen kitchen blades.

==Manual== Manual sharpening is slow, and stock removal even slower. Nevertheless some people prefer this approach.

===Stones=== Oilstones are abrasive stones that work well with oil.

Wetstones are abrasive stones that work best wetted with water.

Diamond sharpening stones are flat plates coated with diamond dust. Diamond will grind even the hardest materials, such as ceramic knives.

===Steel=== A traditional steel doesn't grind. Rather it restores a microscopically bent cutting edge by restraightening it. These were traditionally used between sharpenings as an intermediate way to prolong sharpness.

Modern performance knives don't use steel that suffers this fate, so a steel isn't much use with them. However cheaper knives do use softer metal, and can benefit from use of a steel.

===Abrasive Steel=== The abrasive steel is a traditional steel but with some added abrasive. It primarily acts like a traditional steel, but also provides a little grinding as well, thus prolonging sharpening intervals further. However hand powered grinding of any sort is a labour intensive way to sharpen knives compared to machine grinding.

===Sandpaper=== Abrasive paper may be used on a dead flat surface (eg glass) for sharpening. This has popularly become known as the 'scary sharp' method, as by progressing through increasingly fine grades its possible to achieve a very high level of sharpness.

Several different abrasives are found on abrasive paper, including alox, emery, carbide, zirconium, sharp sand and others. These are frequently loosely referred to as sandpaper. To sharpen steel blades, a sufficiently hard abrasive is required, such as emery, carbide or zirconium.

===Chainsaw file=== The small size makes it slow.

==Motorised== Powered knife sharpening is quicker. ===Kitchen knife sharpener=== Many low cost motorised domestic knife sharpeners are available. One go with one of these caused me to abandon all hope.

There are also good quality machines that can produce a fine edge. Many users like them, but they tend to be pricey.

===Bench grinder=== Bench grinders are the best option in most respects. They are the standard engineer's choice for sharpening a wide range of blades. They don't look particularly graceful in the kitchen though. They also lack the speed of an angle grinder.

===Angle grinder=== The suggestion of using an [[angle grinder]] to sharpen knives often raises eyebrows. However they are very fast and effective, able to sharpen a totally blunt knife in 20-30 seconds, and remove stock to create a new edge in under a minute. This speed makes it easy and practical to sharpen all one's knives quickly, table knives included. For busy people this is a real advantage.

====Flaws==== As sharpeners, angle grinders have some sizeable flaws, and some precautions are very necessary.

The knife blade must be kept moving, don't ever grind one stationary spot. Doing so would overheat the metal in 5-10 seconds, and if this happens the blade will never be able to keep an edge again.

The very high disc speed can throw a knife if held to the disc in the wrong direction. Always confirm the direction of rotation before use (eg with a match etc), and be sure to always hold the knife the right way.

Always use indirect vent goggles, ear defenders, and ideally a full face mask too.

Never use a damp grit disc in an angle grinder, and don't dip cutlery in water to cool it when using such a disc. Damp grit discs can fail violently.

Keep your face out of the plane of rotation of the disc. Grit discs can break violently.

Angle grinder grit discs are somewhat coarse. This coarseness limits the level of sharpness available, but the result is plenty sharp enough for normal kitchen use. It would not satisfy most die hard knife sharpeners though. Use only the very lightest pressure to achieve the sharpest edge.

Don't use these tools if tired, drunk, drugged, or not really with it. They aren't a nice friendly power tool.

====Use==== If you have an angle grinder stand, use it. If not, the tool may be held on its back to minimise fatigue. Sitting down with it on your knees (in your hand of course) makes it easy to pass knives both ways. However you position it, keep a good firm grip at all times.

To sharpen, move the blade as shown past the disc. Use the lightest of pressure only. 2 strokes on each side of the blade is enough for any blade that already has an edge formed, ie doesn't need stock removal. Finally make a burr removing pass along the other side of the blade (compared to the previous stroke). Use all the pressure of a feather, so the blade only just barely touches the disc.

Stock removal requires just a little pressure, and more passes. Never get the metal hot though, if in any doubt just put the knife down and come back to it a bit later. Dipping the knife in water is not recommended with grit discs, damp can cause violent disc failure.

===Die grinder=== Carbide stones (grey) are qiucker than alox (asstd light colours), especially for stock removal.

===Powerfile=== I sharpen most things with a B&D powerfile and it's very effective. If you've not come across this tool before it's like a belt sander but the belts are only 12mm (IIRC) wide. It allows me more control than my angle grinder and is a *lot* safer as the belt is significantly slower and the energy much less. It can be used one-handed quite safely so I usually just hold the knife against a stop with the blade protruding over the edge of the workbench and run the powerfile over it judging the angle by eye. Simple, safe and effective.

=After grinding= Knives should be washed after grinding. Grind stones can harbour all sorts of detritus, oil residues, decayed food & so on.

Its also worth warning the rest of the household if previously blunt knives are now psychopathically sharp.

=Care of sharp knives= Use of 30 degree knives on glass chopping boards or ceramic plates blunts them quickly. Most knife sharpeners prefer wooden chopping boards.

Knives with relatively soft steel benefit from use of a steel between sharpenings.

==See Also==

  • [[Knives]]
  • [[Special:Allpages|Wiki Contents]]
  • [[Special:Categories|Wiki Subject Categories]]

[[Category:Tools]]

Reply to
meow2222

Agreed. I was trying to differentiate from re-grinding a blade that has become too thick to sharpen.

Yes, sorry. Ambiguous. Front face is what faces you with the sharp edge at the bottom and the point pointing to the left. I was pleased to get the explanation of why. Number of sharpening strokes depends on tools you use and the hardness and bluntness of the blade. Say you use three. It's three front, three back, three front.

Hmmm. Not sure about that. Horrible tea better than no tea? Why not learn how to do it? I think that's your motivation in writing this wiki isn't it? I hate cooking in other people's kitchens due to the knives and lack of a decent board. Now I take my own. Deffo nothing but plastic or wood for the board.

I think the spelling is whetstone. It can be dry or wet but is used to whet, or sharpen.

Am I being pedantic?? Don't think so.

Peter Scott

Reply to
Peter Scott

Thanks. I thought it might be something like that. A bit like the stroke on the flat side of a woodcutting chisel.

Peter Scott

Reply to
Peter Scott

Yes, I sharpened some chisels (cheap set, so blunt from new) and they're quite difficult due to needing no taper on 1 side, so making sure that there isn't a burr takes some time.

Reply to
PeterC

You have obviously never seen a steel. I have two carving sets, each comprising a steel, a knife and a fork. The older knife (circa 90 years) has worn down to around 6 inches long, and around 1]4 inch deep, from its original length of 10 inches. It has only been dressed on the steel. When the newer knife (circa 40 years) is sharpened with the steel, minute shavings can, in the right light, be seen falling from the blade. Both steels, when viewed closely, have longitudinally grooves which act as a file. I have never seen a steel without these grooves, and I have seen a hell of a lot of steels.

Reply to
mr fuxit

[...]
[...]

Serrated bread knifes, best thing since sliced bread. Haven't actually used mine on bread but the thing's bloody marvellous for topping off Shreddies cartons and dismembering carboard packages from Ebay. I sharpen it with a cheap sharpener from Lidl. Looks like a plastic sword handle, except it has fitted a little "V" shaped piece of Tungsten Carbide. Just pull a knife through it once or twice. Serrations no problem. A bread knife then segues into a weapon of mass destruction. (Makes me whince just to think how sharp the edge is ;).

Reply to
john jardine

Good for cutting foam for lining equipment boxes too!

Reply to
Bob Eager

why is it when people say 'you have obviously never' theyre so often wrong?

The filing effect is news to me, but I'll include it.

NT

Reply to
meow2222

I think it is worth mentioning that to get an angle of (eg.) 30 degrees with a stone, you sharpen each side of the knife at an angle of 15 degrees! Took me longer than I'd care to admit to realise that...

J^n

Reply to
jkn

Very good point. I have never measured the angle I use when sharpening on a flat diamond surface. It is very shallow and presumably 15 degrees.

Peter Scott

Reply to
Peter Scott

In message , jkn writes

It's also worth mentioning that if the blade has a titanium nitride edge coating you should only sharpen it on the uncoated side.

Reply to
Bernard Peek

How about scissors?

Reply to
The Medway Handyman

I think the distinction between scalloped-edge knives and serrated- edge knives needs to be made clear. Scalloped knives can be re- sharpened on a steel, serrated usually can't without specialised machinery (or if you are 'lucky' enough to have a serrated knife that has a flat face.

I find serrated knives rip their way through things, and clog up with shredded meat, and if used as a bread knife, generate vast quantities of crumbs. My bread knives are scalloped.

Serrated: /\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\ - lots of little pointy teeth, like a saw

Scalloped _--'--_--'--_--'--_ - smoothly curved wave-like edge

I _hate_ using serrated edge knives - tacky, cheap, shoddy, goods. I agree that cutting boards should only be either wood or (softish) plastic - never, ever glass or stone, and don't use a stainless steel counter-top as a cutting board either.

I get the best edge on carbon steel blades using a whetstone, lubricated with oil - for food use, I use olive oil, 'cos it is what I have to hand. When sharp, I can easily shave the hair off the back of my hand with the blade.

Sid

Reply to
unopened

HomeOwnersHub website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.