I guess the other part of it, is where the sensor is located. If sensing that temperature, that's likely sensing the water temperature above the stem-base. You would think the base plate would regularly get hotter than that.
On this one, the trick is, the heater is a "pot" underneath the base, in the center of the percolator base. The thermostatic disc is placed right over on the edge of the pot base, as far away from the heating chamber as they could get it. That's to emulate sensing the water temperature of the upper section of the pot, versus sensing the temperature in the heater pot.
"farberware coffee maker percolator thermostat fix repair"